6 ms·
I know it sounds bad, but some "penalty" (adding a rating system for lies?) should exist for plain lies and fake revisionism in films. The extreme of this in an
by wslh 13y ago
I know it sounds bad, but some "penalty" (adding a rating system for lies?) should exist for plain lies and fake revisionism in films. The extreme of this in another context are the laws against Holocaust denial: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laws_against_Holocaust_denial http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laws_against_Holocaust_denial we can't obviously compare the Steve Jobs film with it, but the cinema has a long tradition of modifying historical facts without the typical disclaimer.
- alexjeffrey 13y agoa recent example of this taken to extremes would be the film "Mermaid: the body found" - pretending to be a documentary claiming evidence of the existence of mermaids, until the credits roll and reveal that the whole film and most of the evidence was a fiction. Granted the subject matter is unlikely, but the deception comes off as very unethical.
- pmelendez 13y agoWell... it is fiction "inspired" by real facts. The point is that people should be aware but that is not the case for the most part.
- throwit1979 13y agoOfftopic. That link is incredibly scary. On what basis does Europe justify making an incorrect opinion illegal? And why that opinion, specifically? Why not criminalize a belief in God, or alien visitation?
- widdershins 13y agoBecause that incorrect belief tries to erase and cover up the murder of millions of people. I'm not sure if that's right, but that is the motivation.
- jbooth 13y agoAt a specific time and place in 1945 this law makes a ton of sense, and it's actually done a lot of good. Compare german - european relations with japanese - chinese/korean/filipino relations. Maybe it should have a sunset provision for the sake of free speech, although I don't think you'll find many MPs signing up to sponsor that bill.
- carlob 13y agoIt's not as simple as that: think about libel laws: if I say that you've stolen something, or that you've killed something and I actively try to ruin your reputation, then my 'opinion' of you is actually very damaging. The same goes for holocaust denial, those who deny the death of millions of people risk repeating history, thus making their 'opinion' dangerous for society at large.
- throwit1979 13y agoBut you're not harming a living human being. At worst, you're minimizing a memory, which is a fundamantally emotional position. As to the risk of repeating history: Anyone positing the holocaust didn't happen is competing in a marketplace of ideas where the evidence is overwhelmingly to the contrary. Not to mention fierce competition from the European equivalent to K-12 education. It seems to me akin to criminalizing street vendors selling hot dogs made of ( sterilized, to minimize health counterarguments ) toe jam and ear wax. Very very few people are going to become customers. Except it's much worse, because you are criminalizing ideas.
- wslh 13y agoAnyone positing the holocaust didn't happen is competing in a marketplace of ideas where the evidence is overwhelmingly to the contrary. You can't believe a country like Germany with one of the strongest cultural and scientific traditions could have accept genocide of such magnitude.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoComing from the UK and having looked into the history of some of my country's behaviour during the height of empire, I have no problem believing that in the slightest. Peccavi.
- claudius 13y agoI doubt you’d be allowed to sell stuff made from toe jam and ear wax for human consumption in most of Europe. Or, even if you were allowed to sell that stuff, you’d need a proper certificate, health and sanitary checks and ensure that your product is indeed safe.
- scotty79 13y agoI think it's because social perception of history is volatile and some experiences came at so much cost that they ought to be remembered correctly.
- booboo2 13y agoIt's not about an "incorrect opinion" though, it's about active proliferation of the lie.
- vidarh 13y agoA substantial part of the justification is that allowing the resurgence of support for nazism is seen as posing a direct risk of genocide and war, and a such a substantial threat to the rights of others. This was further shaped by the experience that the nazi rise to power was propelled by widespread popular support both in Germany and elsewhere, despite the millions that died in World War I just a couple of decades earlier. In comparison, the limited harm done to people who have their speech restricted is seen as a relatively minor tradeoff.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- aet 13y agoIt's not an opinion. For example, the world is flat, not an opinion.
- icecreampain 13y agoThe funny part is that its a specific opinion, also. Questioning the existence of the Holodomor, for example, even though it conservatively resulted in the deaths of 7 million people in one single year, more than the whole "6 million jews in 6 years" thing, is not illegal. In fact most people in Europe are blissfully unaware of the Holodomor at all. Or of Stalin's and Mao's murdered millions. Strange, yes?
- wslh 13y agoWhat is your point? Do you think that the Armenian genocide, together with other genocides should be added to the undeniable things or do you think that the Holocaust denial laws must be "deprecated"?
- icecreampain 13y agoI wish for no thought crimes at all.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoThe laws vary, but in many of these countries, such as the Czech Republic, France, Hungary, Liechtenstein, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Poland and Switzerland, denying those acts would also be illegal and they are far from blissfully unaware of the impact of Stalin and Mao. edit - if you are going to post on the subject of the legal positions on political denial of events, then it helps to do some research to check that you are not actually talking bollocks yourself.
- icecreampain 13y agoI've looked it up real quick but I can't see the Holodomor being illegal to deny in any other country other than the Ukraine. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denial_of_the_Holodomor#Holodomor_denial_and_Ukrainian_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denial_of_the_Holodomor#Holodo... Or are you talking about something else?
- 13y ago
- freehunter 13y agoLies and revisionism in entertainment media is what creates folk stories and folk heroes. It's where a big source of our culture comes from. Folk stories aren't hurting anyone. Take Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Slayer for example. I'm fairly certain Abe didn't kill a single vampire. Or John Henry, the steel driving man. Maybe he did beat a steam drill and die with a hammer in his hands, but he probably didn't. Talk to all the blues singers who tell tales about Stagger Lee killing Billy Lyons. I'm sure they really care about the facts and would love to know that Lee wasn't actually 10ft tall and and that he didn't actually meet the devil himself. Even dating back to Odysseus, did he actually meet the sirens and the cyclops and see his men turned into pigs? Probably not, but it's a damn good story. You'd have to prove malicious intent before anyone could entertain the idea of folk stories causing damage to anyone.