13 ms·
Does Steve Jobs know how to code?
- wsc981 13y agoI wonder if Woz's response is only in context of Apple. IIRC Steve Jobs did actually code when he worked at Atari. Edit: Steve Jobs believed that everyone should learn how to program, I don't think that statement would make any sense if he didn't know how to program himself (even if it's just the basics): http://vimeo.com/64572687 http://vimeo.com/64572687
- angersock 13y ago...if by code, you mean stole and rebranded Woz's designs, you're correct: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakout_%28video_game%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakout_%28video_game%29 This is covered in iWoz--Woz didn't take it super personally, but it was kind of tacky, and Jobs never mentioned the bonus in his payment discussion for a 50/50 split.
- deletes 13y agoHe was hired by Atari int 1973 way before he was assigned to do the Breakout game which was in 1975. I wonder what was his actual job at first. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs#Career http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs#Career
- angersock 13y agoApparently minor design work and modding other peoples' circuits: http://web.archive.org/web/20110612071502/http://www.woz.org/letters/general/91.html http://web.archive.org/web/20110612071502/http://www.woz.org...
- dmourati 13y agoGoogle image search for atari breakout.
- raverbashing 13y ago"Coding" in that context is not as relevant The low-level programming needed for the Apple I is very different from "general programming". It made sense for Woz to do the hardware and the software. In fact I doubt most "coders" of today could do something simple for an Apple I, even given modern resources (like a ASM compiler).
- enry_straker 13y agoWoz was one of a kind. A Mad genius, to paraphrase Ang ( from Avatar the last Airbender ) There is no parallel to him and i don't believe there is anyone who can do both original hardware design and low and high level coding like woz.
- calinet6 13y agoI think there are many people who could, but the skills are no longer as remarkable or required in today's world. Your point is so correct though -- he was a genius, and such diversity of skill should be respected and significantly more valued in the field today.
- mathattack 13y agoWasn't it a slightly less specialized world back then too? The software and hardware were tightly enough linked that you needed someone who could do both. I think Woz is a case of a mad genius being born in the time that suited him. Nowadays a generalist is someone who can do both the front and back end of a website, let alone assembler or hardware. (That's why I find Jeff Atwood's keyboard work interesting, independent of the caliber http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2013/08/the-code-keyboard.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2013/08/the-code-keyboard.h...)
- xradionut 13y ago"Wasn't it a slightly less specialized world back then too?" Yes. Byte had Steve Ciarcia's articles, which were one of the main features of the magazine. We used to modify and build hardware, not just to overclock it, but piggyback memory chips or talk to bench equipment in the lab. By the time I got out of high school, military and university I had: Built a pirated Apple II+, etched circuit boards, worked with 20 different operating systems, built radios, modems, remotes, door openers, set up a BBS, repaired TVs and stereos for beer money, modified a radar system and so on...
- sp332 13y agoWell, this story doesn't make much sense if he knew how to code at Apple. http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Calculator_Construction_Set.txt http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Calculator_Constr...
- threeseed 13y agoSorry but your comment doesn't make much sense. I have been programming for 15+ years. It doesn't mean that I instantly know every application framework in existence. Especially the (looking back at it now) the pretty complex way the original Mac OS apps were written.
- pmelendez 13y agoI think sp332's point is that if you have 15+ years programming and you can't get a guy to produce you what you exactly want, then you would eventually do a prototype by yourself to show them how to do it.
- sp332 13y agoI was thinking, since the drawing functionality was mostly right, Jobs could have tweaked the background color or shadow size manually instead of telling Espinosa to move things around a pixel at a time and waiting for another iteration.
- threeseed 13y agoI am honestly bewildered by your thought process here. If I am getting someone to build me an Android app and I don't know how to do it. Then I am not going to learn Java, SDK, tool chain, build process and buy a device just to show them how to do it. I am going to send them an email and tell them to change it and go back and forth until I am happy.
- pmelendez 13y agoI don't think you got my point about the story. The pregrammer made an UI utility in few hours so Jobs could design the calculator the way he wanted. A prototype can be done in whatever you already know, so there is no need to learn anything outside your current skill set. If you aren't able to produce that then probably your programming skills are not higher enough and hence you could say that you can't code (not that is a bad thing anyway)
- joeblau 13y agoDid he write code in NeXTSTEP? I guess that wouldn't be a question for Woz.
- JPKab 13y agoNot trying to minimize anything he did with NeXT, but I would be shocked if he did the coding for it..... he was already wealthy, and was an executive trying to launch a premium product. I'm sure he had a vision for it, but it wouldn't make sense for him to have been bogged down at that level.
- chiph 13y agoThere was a demo he did of NeXTSTEP where he coded some stuff (can't provide a link - work blocks streaming video). It's certainly possible that he memorized it, but he didn't have any hesitations so I think he had more than a casual familiarity with it.
- Ynot_82 13y ago"Does", as opposed to "Did"? Cue jokes about dead code, bit-rot, etc.
- Sagat 13y agoHow much technical experience did Jobs actually have? Did he actually have a part in designing all the successful products or was he just a manager and marketer? I don't mean to diss Jobs or imply that he wasn't important, but I don't clearly understand what his role was in Apple's success.
- chollida1 13y ago> but I don't clearly understand what his role was in Apple's success. His role was basically convincing woz to: a) start AAPL as a company b) quit his job an HP c) sell the Apple 1 instead of giving it away. Needless to say he was pretty important:)
- threeseed 13y agoHonestly it's just ignorance on your part. If you watch some of the presentations Jobs gave e.g. during his NeXt days it's pretty clear that he absolutely understands every bit of the technology as good as any engineering manager. The ability to combine technical knowledge with exceptional design, marketing and product development skills is what made him vital to Apple's success.
- bdcravens 13y agoImportant distinction: understanding the technology != coding. I think alot of folks who worship Jobs here believe saying he couldn't code is some sort of ultimate insult. It's not; he understood his products. I've met many programmers who have no clue about the product they're building, and some who barely grok the tech outside of their area of responsibility.
- rythie 13y ago"just a manager and marketer?" You realize that late 70s and early 80s were full of 100s companies trying to do the same exact thing as Apple right? Just like there were 100s of competitors to Facebook, Dropbox, Reddit and anything you can think of. Building a successful business is much much harder than building a product - I'm sorry, but speaking as someone who codes, there is no shortage of good technical people really, there is a shortage of people that can build multi-billion dollar businesses from nothing.
- soneca 13y agoKind of OT, but a little sad thing I noticed in the "Jobs" movie trailer (at least the version they are showing in Brazil) is that while the images are clearly showing Woz showing what he did (Apple I) and then he and Jobs working together all the time, the text was saying "It only takes one person... ...to start a revolution". WTF?! One person? I am not even making any moral judgement here, I am just shocked of how schizophrenic it is. People don't even bother about coherence any more? And them the movie goes on to show another people joining, two more engineers, a investor. It was just weird...
- angersock 13y agoIt's part of the mythos--nevermind the engineers that actually built anything.
- Sagat 13y agoThis is probably just a side effect of the legacy that led to this film being made in the first place... the mythology surrounding Jobs.
- danso 13y agoThat's just sad, and something that inspires an all too common megalomania among wanna-be CEOs who think that, if they have the same ego as Steve Jobs, that their vision and passion shall too drive a revolution. Woz was the critical factor to Apple's early success, and the momentum the Apple ][ bequeathed gave Jobs the significant runway to make real his vision. And vice versa, being a stellar engineer alone won't necessarily lead you to success...Woz readily admits at he'd still be at HP, making calculators, if it weren't for Jobs (though Woz would be content either way because, well, he's the Woz)
- michaelwww 13y agoThis is the most balanced comment on this thread I've read so far. Woz and Jobs were the Yin and Yang of Apple's success. Comparing the two misses the bigger picture. I don't really get the reason for the argument: I never hear people arguing about Ben and Jerry, Gates and Allen, or Hewlett and Packard. The only reason I can think of is that for some people Jobs has ascended to heaven where he reigns as a god with no equal.
- danso 13y agoIssacson's biography doesn't indicate that Jobs ever wrote code, but at the very least we can say that he was one of the few non-coders who didn't treat it as a fungible commodity given that he literally threw a crying tantrum to get Woz to co-found Apple. Also this: http://www.npr.org/2011/10/06/141115121/steve-jobs-computer-science-is-a-liberal-art http://www.npr.org/2011/10/06/141115121/steve-jobs-computer-... > "In my perspective ... science and computer science is a liberal art, it's something everyone should know how to use, at least, and harness in their life. It's not something that should be relegated to 5 percent of the population over in the corner. It's something that everybody should be exposed to and everyone should have mastery of to some extent, and that's how we viewed computation and these computation devices."
- TheFucker 13y agoNo, he's dead!
- npalli 13y agoIt looks like the response was written when Jobs was still around. I doubt Woz would sound so belligerent now. In any case, if you watch some of Job’s old videos and biographical material, it was clear he knew coding. There was some mainframe terminal in his high school that he first learnt how to code. Now Woz was clearly Genius level when it came to tight hardware/software engineering. So, it is not at all surprising Jobs had limited input when it came to the Apple I and II design. In fact Jobs mentions that Woz was the first guy who knew more about electronics than he (Jobs) did. In Woz’s response, quoted here, he mentions that Jobs was technical enough to alter/change/add to the design. Does that sound like someone who doesn’t know anything? I find it sad that engineers project their own insecurities in this whole Jobs/Woz saga. Jobs was highly involved in not just the technical aspects but the overall vision of Apple I, II, Macintosh, iPod, iPhone, iPad. He was one of a kind. There is no need to pull him down and artificially elevate Woz to something he was not. Jobs could work with the best engineers/marketeers/design/retail people during Apple II and the iPad. A whole 35 year period in technology. How would you think Woz would have fared in deep technical discussions involving the iPhone? How many engineers do you know who have worked at the highest level for 35 years? Technology was only one of the aspects that Jobs understood quite well.
- goblin89 13y agoPage source indicates that this has been posted on 05 Jun, 2012. (Submission dates are invisible because of a CSS rule.)
- 3JPLW 13y agoI'm guessing the submission dates are hidden because they're incorrect. Here's another one[0] that says it was posted in 2011, but there's an ed mark saying that "at this time" meant "pre-2000." Edit: It's on the wayback machine since at least August of 2000.[1] [0]. http://www.woz.org/letters/relationship-steve-jobs http://www.woz.org/letters/relationship-steve-jobs [1]. http://web.archive.org/web/20000817233800/http://www.woz.org/letters/general/08.html http://web.archive.org/web/20000817233800/http://www.woz.org...
- hvs 13y ago
- jamesjguthrie 13y agoIn the 'Lost Interview' of 1995, Steve Jobs says that he was programming at the HP Palo Alto lab, on the 9100 in BASIC and ATL. He would "hang around that machine and write programs for it" http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=m8mttU82V64#t=299 http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=m8m...
- MarlonPro 13y agoWoz's response exactly conforms to Jobs' account on the topic in his biography, "Steve Jobs" by Walter Isaacson. Woz's response is not all belligerent, as somebody here implied.
- kyllo 13y agoThere are degrees of knowing how to code. Did Jobs know enough to write a simple program? Probably. Was it ever his job to write programs? Did he ever contribute code at Apple? Probably not.
- FridayWithJohn 13y agoSilly title. It should be "Did".
- millerm 13y agoNo, it's the title of the original post.
- hbharadwaj 13y agoIt is quite an irony. If an engineer were to come across a "Jobs" like character, he/she would ignore him/her for the most part. This makes it harder for a "Jobs" like character to make a breakthrough to big stages. To me, he was a brilliant Product Manager. I have seen really good Product Managers who could not write a "select *" query. They have a sense of technology like no others in the sense that they can apply technological solutions to real life problems and envision product futures. They don't care as much about the intrinsic details. Every time I see a post on HN stating "Here are the things I look for in a Product Manager", I begin envisioning Jobs trying to take on such tests and it is quite funny.
- spiritplumber 13y agoApple founder guy who specialized in bullshit is dead. Apple founder guy who specialized in real work is alive. Insert witty Kurt Vonnegut quote here.
- cesarfarias 13y agoIt's all logic and imagination.
- denzil_correa 13y agoQ: Does Steve Jobs know how to code? A: Steve Jobs never wrote code Woz doesn't say Jobs didn't know to code. He merely says that he didn't code at Apple.
- NDizzle 13y agoWoz is a badass.
- known 13y ago"The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man." --George Bernard Shaw
- jt2190 13y agoCan someone explain to me why I should care whether Steve Jobs could code or not? Is there some lesson to learn here?
- MrBra 13y agoCould you explain us why you read the article if you already knew you wouldn't care ?
- KeepTalking 13y agoDoes it really matter whether he knew to code or not ? Job's area of brilliance was complimenting to Woz's technical competence and they both managed to stay "generally" out of each others way yet focused on the same goal.
- bdcravens 13y agoI listen to a lot of entrepreneurial podcasts, mostly focused on bootstrapping, with an emphasis on SaaS products. On these shows, the entrepreneur is king. They often emphasize outsourcing to VAs, which makes sense. However, I see some of them with an attitude that technical skills are of this same value: something you just buy when you need it, as cheap as possible. Yesterday I think it was the Smart Passive Income podcast I was listening to where they (Pat had a guest) encouraged going to vWorker (yes, I know it's been acquired) if you need a developer to implement something. Part of me was angry; the other part of me realized the truth of what they were saying. On one hand, some companies require their technology to be a competitive advantage. At a company like Apple, this isn't the case. The tech in their products is actually pretty good, but that's not what sells the products. Yes, they'll mention processor speeds etc at WWDC to thunderous applause, but then you'll never hear those things mentioned in the marketing. Apple has always been about vision, beauty, and simplicity. During Jobs's hiatus, they went down the multiple configurations and flexibility route; Jobs revamped their line and simplified it when he returned. The tech facilitates, doesn't lead.
- simonebrunozzi 13y agoWhat's Steve Wozniak's email?
- pbreit 13y agoThought experiment: which was more likely, Jobs being successful without Woz or Woz being successful without Jobs? I put my net worth on Jobs.
- tn13 13y agoThere is also matter of perspective here. Woz is that hardware/software genius and hence what he means by "knowing to code" is really different than the person who asked the question. Woz seems to have interpreted it as "knowing some programming language to the extent of making some significant contribution".
- ruexperienced 13y agoI don't have time to read all the comments. But from the first several ones I read it seems that folks, for a change, missed Woz's response. Woz didn't say that Steve couldn't or didn't know how to code, but that "Steve didn't ever code." Very different answers! I mean, even a monkey can be tough how to code at least at some level. Now, the level at which Woz was coding was not your standard Ruby scripting mombo jumbo, and hence it's a world apart from what some folks consider coding, which is implicit in what he's saying. Also by Woz saying that "(Steve) wasn't an engineer," he was clearly stating the fact that Steve at that point in time was more about the business, the direction of things and the big picture rather than the nitty gritty stuff for which he had Woz to do it for him/them. All in all, lets be honest, Steve forte was never ever his technical prowess. I'm sure some business majors here, who get away with getting other folks do to stuff for them, truly believe they are very technical as well, even though they don't know shit! Steve definitely had a good eye at what could and couldn't sell, particularly at the end of his career. Now, what Steve was really good about was in getting very good technical folks in house and getting away in pushing them to the limit of exploitation, because after all it was Steve Jobs. Hence, he was great at causing confusion and manipulation, which is why he was so good at marketing. If Woz wouldn't have been around, Apple simply wouldn't have existed with Steve alone. Now, Steve was definitely a hustler and probably would have started another type of business, but we simply wouldn't know about it.
- shocknawesome 13y agoOh look another engineer whining because he didn't have the vision or business chops to create something great on his own. Woz was an idiot who would have given Apple's original technology away and NOTHING would have come from it as a result. If you enjoy Apple's products at all you should thank Steve. Woz was replaceable as Apple's history has shown; they have grown immensely without his involvement.