4 ms·
There is no intrinsic value. There is no unchanging market value. There is only the market value now, and the market value it used to have, and for that matter
by jerf 18y ago
There is no intrinsic value. There is no unchanging market value. There is only the market value now, and the market value it used to have, and for that matter the definition of "market" isn't terribly obvious either, though the only ones that matter are "people I can actually sell the thing to" and "the average of the market for some purpose or other".
This is the way it is. Complaining about it doesn't change anything. Market value may be nebulous, but it's the least nebulous meaningful definition of "value" there is for commerce.
(This is why I can't even be a "goldbug". The idea that gold has intrinsic value is patently absurd, because there is no such thing as "intrinsic value". And once you are reduced to arguing that "Well, historically it's been a good investment" it is simply one commodity amoungst many and the argument is over, because now gold isn't special.)
- stcredzero 18y agoI never commented in support of "intrinsic value." Specifically, the "market value" of legal tender is arguably problematic. There are well established instruments that can be used to determine the market values of things like cars and electricity and the metals in coins. However, "legal tender" status has a clear precedent for confounding this. A penny is a penny, and an employer who pays with older coins whose copper and nickel content is worth more than their face value wouldn't be liable for additional tax.
- jerf 17y ago'I never commented in support of "intrinsic value."' I know, it was part of a larger point. You did seem to imply the existence of some sort of "real market value", though, which would somehow transcend transient fluctuations, but those transient fluctuations are all that exist. Even money doesn't have a real market value; a dollar is only worth what people will give you for it. My point is that the nebulousness can be fixed by anything I said; my point is that the nebulousness is irreducible, and all attempts to make it less nebulous, no matter how necessary they may be for things like tax law, will inevitably be a leaky abstraction to the underlying chaos. So, complaining that a particular abstraction is leaky isn't very useful, they all will be.