193 ms·
Land deals in Africa and Asia: Cornering foreign fields
- potatolicious 17y agoVery interesting article - and we can see the effects of this sort of land ownership historically, particularly with regards to American multi-national agriculture giants. From what I know of the situation, the effects of these massive land buy-outs are rarely positive. Yes, it generates employment locally, but it creates a trade deficit for the host country like you would not believe, and drives everyone into poverty in the long run. Not to mention that many of these countries are starving, and instead of using the land to grow food crops and feed the people, they're exporting bananas and pineapples, and re-importing staple foods that they're not growing themselves at high prices. This behaviour has led to revolutions in the past - and we know that the ousting of the socialist Salvadore Allende in Chile (by the CIA, no less) was fueled largely due to American corporate objections over nationalization of farmlands. And then he was replaced by Pinochet - a story we would be better off not repeating. Whatever the benefits of this sort of deal, I'm fairly certain the farmers at on the fields are not seeing it. Massive land buy-outs like these benefit only the gilded upper classes of these poor countries.
- patrickg-zill 17y agoRead up on Benetton in Argentina also.
- seldo 17y agoThis reminds me of the Transnationals described in Kim Stanley Robinson's Red-Green-Blue Mars trilogy (which won an award for its realistic portrayal of economics). Basically, the multinationals found small countries with a GDP much smaller than their own profits and bought the whole country: land, infrastructure, and government. Then they refashioned the laws of that country through corruption and bribery to fit themselves and began operating at a level parallel to the governments of other countries, rather than being subject to their laws. In this case, the governments of Saudi Arabia, China, etc., worried that the countries that supply them with raw materials will pass laws restricting exports, are buying massive portions of the production capacity of these exporting countries to essentially make it impossible for these countries to sell goods to anybody else. It's simultaneously a clever and sinister form of neo-colonialism.
- 3pt14159 17y agoI'd buy land in these countries if I had an army backing my land claim. In general, I have a strong dislike for national investments like these. If the only difference between me and China is that I can't trust their courts/government and China can, due to China's large stock piles of guns, then it presents an unfair (and illiquid) market place.