4 ms·
And, empirically, property existed long before governments.
by baddox 13y ago
And, empirically, property existed long before governments.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoHow can you have ownership without protection?
- baddox 13y agoPeople can and do protect what they believe to be their property. Families and tribes can and do protect the territory they believe to belong to their members. I like David Friedman's description of property rights not primarily as moral or legal constructs, but as mutually recognized commitment strategies which discourage trespasses. He points out that territorialism in the animal kingdom is similar to property rights (obviously without the existence of a state). Animals mark their territory (e.g. with urine), and other animals tend to respect those boundaries, because there is mutual understanding that the territory holder will fight a trespasser to the death if necessary, and the damage to the trespasser (even a stronger trespasser) will most likely not be worth it. Perhaps the territory holder would be better off just retreating, but what makes it "property" is the near certainty that he won't retreat. http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Order_without_the_state/Order_Without_the_State.htm http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Order_without_the_sta...
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI would call that a state; why is it not a state?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- baddox 13y agoTo clarify: you call territorialism in the animal kingdom a state?
- foobarbazqux 13y agoSure, why not? Humans are animals, after all.
- baddox 13y agoI would prefer a more specific definition that would match more closely to people's intuition about what is and isn't a state, and also allows for discussion about what the state should and shouldn't do. If we define "state" as to include animals protecting their territory, I don't see how the term will be very useful in any discussion.
- kaonashi 13y agoI think it's a specific rejection of the notion that there ever existed a time before governments. Governments existed, in some form, the moment particles started interacting.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI hadn't thought of it in those terms but I like that understanding of governments. A cell is a state, its laws are its DNA, and its borders are its membrane; and not just metaphorically speaking.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoOne useful reason to define states as such is because it's a definition that draws on the natural world. If states are only natural, and inevitable, then we don't have to argue about whether they are fundamentally good or bad. What is your definition of a state?
- iopq 13y agoa state has to: 1) tax people who live there 2) threaten people who don't pay with force otherwise, it has no resources of its own, so it doesn't exist as an entity
- foobarbazqux 13y agoHow is this not the case in the residential pride of lions where the 5-6 lionesses do the hunting for the 1-2 male lion leaders? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lion#Group_organization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lion#Group_organization
- humanrebar 13y agoWhether your property is stolen or not, it ought to be yours. The enforcement of a right is not necessary for a right to exist.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoEnforcement is necessary for a natural right to be a legal right.
- a-priori 13y agoWell yes, as soon as a creature needs to expend energy to obtain a thing they plan on using later, another creature is going to try to obtain it in a simpler way: by stealing it. And so, even apes and birds have a concept of 'property': things that are theirs, usually cached food, that they will take pains to hide and/or defend. With humans it isn't quite so clear. The default societal structure for humans is the band, which is basically an extended family unit. In a band, property is shared by the group. If a member of another band sneaks in and takes something, that's theft and will result in retaliation. So a concept of property exists at the band level. But I don't believe that individual members of a band have stuff they are allowed to use but no one else. It's only in more complex societies that private property at the individual level definitely exists. But these societies also have some form of government, even if it's just a tribal chief. So if by 'property' you mean private (i.e, individual) property, it's not quite so clear which came first: property or government.
- iopq 13y agoExcept that's not true. Monkeys are supposed to give the eggs or other food items that they find to the senior members of their group. But sometimes they'll eat them when nobody is looking, or if they create a diversion (like they'll call like a predator is coming) so theft can be done in group, especially when there's scarcity