5 ms·
The OP is written like he thinks he just made up the idea of applying the phrase 'cargo cult' to IT. Nope, it's got a long history. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki
by jrochkind1 13y ago
The OP is written like he thinks he just made up the idea of applying the phrase 'cargo cult' to IT. Nope, it's got a long history. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult#Metaphorical_uses_of_the_term http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult#Metaphorical_uses_of...
It's also not clear that the story told about the 'primitve' folks and their weird mistaken beliefs is actually a historically accurate one. Which the wikipedia article also addresses in part.
I find a blog post that just regurgitates the 'cargo cult' metaphor as if the author had invented it, and also without doing any research into the accuracy of the actual story he's telling about "Papua New Guinea" -- to be kind of insulting to the reader, and lazy on his part.
- jaf12duke 13y agoThe criticism of my writing style is fair. My intention was to spread the concept in an interesting style, not act as if I made it up. I may have failed in that attempt and, if so, I apologize. As a small piece of proof that I didn't try to act as if I made it up--I linked to the Wikipedia post about the term cargo culting.
- dccoolgai 13y agoThe underlying logical concept has a much longer history than even the existence of IT... or cargo cults for that matter. Look up the "Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc" logical fallacy, which cargo cults are a manifestation of.
- rjsw 13y agoI think that the promise of future "cargo" in some form makes a difference in how the cult participants behave and on the personality types of those who choose to join, both leaders and followers. I think there is more involved than just the logical fallacy itself. I have been thinking about cargo cults a fair bit recently in a (non IT) area.
- qu4z-2 13y agoAs far as I can tell, the original "cargo cults" were pretty much exactly a manifestation of that fallacy. Could you explain what else is involved that I may be missing? EDIT: On further reading, I think I have a better idea now, but I'd still be interested in your thoughts.
- mathattack 13y ago42 floors is a great company, and I enjoy reading what they have to say. But with that said, I agree with you. And what's worse, the overuse "Cargo Cult" is turning it into a negative version of one of the meaningless buzzwords that he decries. If you don't like something, just call it a "Cargo Cult".