3 ms·
Clearly the IRS prefers the interpretation that your 'nominal' payment was actually $50K (or included a $47.5K gift) -- so tax is owed even if the recipient sit
by gojomo 17y ago
Clearly the IRS prefers the interpretation that your 'nominal' payment was actually $50K (or included a $47.5K gift) -- so tax is owed even if the recipient sits on the coins.
If in fact someone immediately sold the coins and reported the nominal payment plus the short-term 'investment gain', it might push the matter below the level of IRS concern. My understanding is that when the net tax effect is about the same from alternate accountings, the IRS is unlikely to quibble about the particulars (but IANAL or tax accountant).
- kqr2 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gift_tax_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gift_tax_in_the_United_States In theory, you are allowed to gift up to the $13K tax free each year. I wonder if he could claim that up to $13K minus the nominal value of the coins was a gift.
- tptacek 17y agoI understand the competing preferences here, but even in this guy's best-case scenario, he hasn't avoided income tax; he's just shifted it from payroll tax (which is FICA eligible) to capital gains. You can do a similar thing as an independent contractor just by forming an S-Corp and claiming your income as profit sharing instead of salary. And of course the outcome is similar: you enjoy a nominal benefit for awhile, and then you get audited and taken to court. I don't think the IRS is shaking in their boots over this.
- gojomo 17y agoRight -- the only significant gain is if the coins are held longer (for long-term gains treatment of the phony appreciation) or sold in an unreported transaction (which itself compounds the illegality). And my point was: while any combination of stunts leading to less taxes paid is of interest to the IRS, if you instead engage in bizarro accounting but the end result is you wind up paying about the same amount of taxes, just via different line-item -- no "net tax effect" -- they may as a practical matter ignore you. They care about the money, not the principle.