3 ms·
"you can't feasibly build a 1 kbps transceiver with 16 mW transmit power and a two inch monopole antenna and expect to get anywhere near half a km of range with
by TaylorAlexander 13y ago
"you can't feasibly build a 1 kbps transceiver with 16 mW transmit power and a two inch monopole antenna and expect to get anywhere near half a km of range with the TI radio"
I mean... you say that, but we did, and we're not doing anything special, I just set two android phones to volley their GPS position over USB to the board, send it over radio, and calculate the distance on the other end. I then verified the calculations manually using google earth and landmarks.
Here's what texas instruments has to say [1] about the radio:
"You can achieve a range of several km with the CC1101 without any problems (line of sight). The output power can be programmed up to 12dBm and the sensitivity level on the receiver is dependent on the programmed baud rate. With a sensitivity of -112dBm and an output power of 12dBm, 915MHz ; the expected range with Friis equation adapted to take into account the height from the ground would be approx 3km."
We're being advised by Earl McCune, a serious Silicon Valley Radio expert (google him, he's awesome), and he donated some of his time to help test the board with his nice Agilent RF stuff. He was impressed with the performance of this little chip, and was also impressed that my layout nearly perfectly matches the TI reference design.
[1] http://e2e.ti.com/support/low_power_rf/f/155/t/15984.aspx http://e2e.ti.com/support/low_power_rf/f/155/t/15984.aspx
- ohazi 13y agoWait, so you're not using the additional TI power amp? Well shit... Now you have my attention. I obviously missed something if I was off by two orders of magnitude. I'll take a closer look when I have some more time. In the meantime, I would strongly suggest adding as many technical details to the kickstarter page as you can (output power, for starters. A (rough) schematic would be fantastic). Edit: Actually, do you have any specs on the antennas you've tested?
- kbaker 13y agoBack of the envelope, and assuming their design is the same like their board pictures posted on the kickstarter page (i.e. no PA, all RF done inside the chip): The CC1200 puts out 14 dBm [1]. Receive Sensitivity from the datasheet at 915 MHz is -122 dBm @ 1200 baud, -110 dBm @ 50 kbps, and -97 dBm @ 500 kbps. Very good overall. (all these values are from the datasheet.) Free space ideal path loss at 915 MHz and 1 km is -91.7 dB [2]. This gives an ideal budget of 44 dB. Toss in some antenna gain and you should have plenty to play around with for losses in the passives, connectors, antenna alignment, etc. 3 km is pushing it, with another 10 dB of path loss. So I would think 1 kilometer is easily attainable at 1200 baud with this chip. However, things start to change with FCC compliance... 15.249 devices (a lot less limitations, including fixed frequency) can transmit at max -1 dBm. [3] So the compliant device at 50 kbps, -1 dBm, 1 km has 15 dB ideal budget, right on the edge of working. 500 kbps is probably not going to happen at 1 km except in perfect conditions. So now you want to use hopping as a 15.247 device to get the limit up to 30 dBm/1 Watt. This chip doesn't support DSSS, so we are frequency hopping. This limits us to a channel bandwidth of 500 kHz, so you can't run at high speeds - maybe 200 kbps or so? Downside is you are spending some time hopping and waiting for PLLs to stabilize, there is a chance for interference on certain frequencies resulting in periodic dropouts until you hop to the next frequency, and the software side/hopping coordination is tons more complex. But you would be able to communicate pretty far! Also, note that RF is very unfriendly and link budgets can easily be used up with obstacles in the way, walls, trees, not to mention pesky humans etc. Hopefully this clarifies some things? Please let me know as well if I am off anywhere, I know a little about this but it is also late... [1] http://www.ti.com/product/cc1200 http://www.ti.com/product/cc1200 (see datasheet) [2] http://www.qsl.net/pa2ohh/jsffield.htm http://www.qsl.net/pa2ohh/jsffield.htm [3] http://rfcalculator.mobi/convert-dbuv-3m.html http://rfcalculator.mobi/convert-dbuv-3m.html, 15.249 allows 50 mV/m @ 3m = 93.89 dbuV/m @ 3m = -1.34 dBm EIRP. [4] FCC 15.247 & 15.249