4 ms·
I was soooo tempted to troll that comment :-) I am struck however by the agreement by the judge and the ex-robber that 5 years is about the max you should give
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
I was soooo tempted to troll that comment :-)
I am struck however by the agreement by the judge and the ex-robber that 5 years is about the max you should give if hoping to reform someone.
> In the “for what it is worth” category, I have thought
> for a long time that 60 months was about the maximum
> sentence one should impose if you were were solely hoping
> to make a positive impact on the prisoner.
It would be interesting if we genuinely tried prison as a reform institution. Stop the violence, stop the drugs, provide real meaningful work, and ... err.
- rayiner 13y agoIt was intellectually in vogue in the 1960's to treat prison as a reform institution. Then the 1970's and 1980's happened, and the great cities of the U.S. dissolved in crime and violence, and those ideas went very much out of style. I think it's an unfortunate accident of history more than anything else. When I was growing up in the 1990's, us suburbanites from Northern Virginia would never dream of going to D.C. at night. What took the capital of the country and dragged it down into that sorry state was a combination of economic issues, the drug war, deteriorating race relations, political conflict, etc. But whatever the cause was, it happened, and the end result was that we had an entire generation of people (the boomer generation), that saw the purpose of the criminal law as keeping the criminal element from spilling out into civilized society. Hence, the focus was, through the 1990's, "victims rights" and "tough on crime" not rehabilitation.
- cstross 13y agowhatever the cause was, it happened The incarceration rate since the 1960s has remained virtually static; but the incarcerees are in prison, where previously they would have been detained in mental asylums: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/saving-normal/201303/prison-or-treatment-the-mentally-ill http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/saving-normal/201303/pri... Also note the strong correlation between falling crime rates since 1970 and the removal of tetraethyl lead as an additive in gasoline: http://www.economist.com/blogs/theworldin2013/2013/01/lead-and-crime http://www.economist.com/blogs/theworldin2013/2013/01/lead-a... A punitive prison regime isn't going to cure the sick. What we need is to swing the focus onto mental health issues -- and yes, this may mean building new asylums, to replace the punishment regime of prisons with a medical/treatment oriented system -- and shrink the prison system and re-focus it on actual criminals rather than unfortunates who hear voices in their heads.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoHuh? Lead causes crime?
- khuey 13y agoUh, yeah. It's pretty widely accepted that lead-induced brain damage from tetraethyl lead fuel additives was a contributor to crime in the mid to late 20th century.
- danielweber 13y agoIt's a very decent theory, but don't confuse someone agreeing that spending money to reduce environmental lead is a good bet (where the standard of proof is not extremely strict, and that's a good thing) with someone saying that "lead causes crime." Just because Kevin Drum likes it doesn't make it "widely accepted." You oversell his theory. It's proven about as well as abortion reducing crime, which has good evidence behind it but is hardly a slam-dunk case.
- patrickmclaren 13y agoCorrelates with, does not necessarily cause.
- sanj 13y agoAgreed, but correlation across multiple countries across multiple time windows, indicate that we should pay attention to it. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0013935107000503 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0013935107...
- mcherm 13y agoBut it is difficult to imagine a mechanism where the lead could be caused by the crime and easy to imagine one where the crime is caused by the lead. A separate independent cause that affects crime and lead is easy to imagine, but if you control for location where people live, or lived when young (which is largely a measure of poverty) and still saw the correlation between lead and crime, then I would say that was quite strong evidence that lead poisoning (which is known to have mental effects) causes behavior patterns that lead to crime.
- hyperventilator 13y agoWhen Tocqueville (Democracy in America) came to the US in the 1830's it was to study prison reform for the French government. He wrote about an experiment at a youth reformatory that was run democratically by the inmates. No one ever lost their right to vote no matter what they did, but if you behaved you got two votes and could affect the outcome of decisions more. Apparently this worked very well.
- angersock 13y agoOne wonders how much of that was a function of more draconian drug laws, both in directly creating offenders and in indirectly creating markets which incentivized criminal behavior.
- Ziomislaw 13y ago> It would be interesting if we genuinely tried prison as a reform institution. Stop the violence, stop the drugs, provide real meaningful work, and ... err. Where is the money in that? Your "clientele" numbers might actually go down - less prisoners == less money.
- warfangle 13y agoAnd then you'd have to import prisoners, like the Netherlands...
- rayiner 13y agoThe money explanation is phat, but there isn't much to it. The vast, vast majority of prisoners in the U.S. are housed in public prisons, which cost taxpayers tons of money. Moreover, the explosion in incarceration rate predates the use of private, for-profit prisons. It's always convenient to lay the blame on some corporation, but the fact is that voters wanted long sentences and got them. They would rather spend large amounts of money keeping convicts locked up than have those people walking around in public. Note the political change that happened in the 1990's. Prior to the 1990's, democrats talked a lot about prisoners rights. Republicans crucified them as "soft on crime" and countered with "victims rights" which was much more popular. As a result, today there is almost no difference between the two parties when it comes to the criminal justice system, except maybe when it comes to the death penalty. Being "soft on crime" is a political non-starter in the U.S.
- masklinn 13y ago> It would be interesting if we genuinely tried prison as a reform institution. Yes, until the 70s. People came from all over the world to see the californian prison system.
- astrodust 13y agoWhat was unique about California?
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoIt was in a sunny, rich state, next to Hollywood, and you could get there with the expenses account on the prison budget. The Cuban medical system is considered world-class for very similar reasons. :-)
- kbenson 13y agoIt used to be the model for reform, with many education and work skills programs so leaving inmates would have a career to enter upon leaving. I believe it had one of (if the the) lowest recidivism rates in the country. Here's some relevant quotes from an article I found[1], I've heard a few programs about the prison system during that period on the radio: Before 1977, all California prisoners had an indeterminate sentence. They were given a range of time in which they would be imprisoned, with five years to life being a common sentence. To be freed, inmates had to prove to the parole board that they deserved it, which could mean enrolling in reform-oriented programs, learning a trade, or taking classes. The aim of indeterminate sentencing was to rehabilitate prisoners and, when they were ready to reenter society, free them. Although the system had its flaws, it also had its successes. According to state statistics, just 15 percent of inmates released in 1977 returned to California prisons — an extraordinarily low recidivism rate in comparison to today. Nonetheless, in 1977, then- Governor Jerry Brown signed a law that completely overhauled the state's sentencing system, switching the focus from rehabilitation to punishment. [1]: http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/how-the-prison-population-exploded/Content?oid=3172693
- Symmetry 13y agoThe problem is that in a prison most of the people there are going to be criminals, and will end up socializing each other in ways that act against reform. Though another part of the problem is that whenever you have a justice system anyone singled out by it as a criminal is going to have an easier time being trusted by criminals and a harder time being trusted by non-criminals in the future.
- at-fates-hands 13y ago>>>and will end up socializing each other in ways that act against reform. There's no incentive for people to reform which is a huge issue with the current prison culture. You're just trying to survive 24/7, align yourself with a gang for protection and hope you can make it without getting caught or extending your sentence. The whole system is set up for people to go to jail and get better at committing crimes.
- alex-g 13y agoThe prison gang system is also supported by (some of) the warders, because it makes their job easier. Not just because some of them may receive bribes, but also because they come to rely on gang authority to keep any kind of order.
- MaysonL 13y agoThere's another judge whose thoughts on sentencing are summed up as: there are two classes of people whom I sentence; the ones I'm mad at, and the ones I'm afraid of. I save long sentences for the second class.