7 ms·
Sadly Germans hate credit cards.
by k__ 13y ago
Sadly Germans hate credit cards.
- donw 13y agoI'm in an office in Berlin as I type this. Every person around me has a credit card. Every German I personally know, including my destitute student friends, have credit cards. It's not like online retail isn't a huge business here, and credit cards are the easiest payment method available, due to the incredibly restrictive nature of German banks. A lot of startups here have been screaming for this day.
- k__ 13y agoI have one, too. The younger generation is okay with this, but most older people prefere "real" money :\
- qznc 13y agoDirect debit is just as easy. Two numbers to enter.
- pc 13y agoThe problem is that you can't synchronously process the payment, which makes the API (and user experience generally) much more complicated.
- chrisboesing 13y agoDo you plan on supporting direct debit in the future or is your focus on expanding to more countries before adding more payment options?
- pc 13y agoWe're thinking about it, but it's not clear to us that we can create an abstraction that fits nicely with everything else. I'm not sure that the additional complexity would be worth it. Definitely open to any suggestions.
- Atropos 13y agoThere is one German company offering a solution (https://www.sofort.com/eng-DE/ https://www.sofort.com/eng-DE/), but as far as I know, it's still unclear if their users don't break their own banks' ToS-
- collision 13y agoIf you're using Sofort, then there's an off-site redirect involved and it's no longer as simple as entering two numbers.
- mhd 13y agoIn what way? As a user, you get your order confirmation and while it might take a bit longer for the money to arrive, that's really not even noticeable for most e-commerce transactions. I much prefer debit, as it makes it much easier for me to get my money back if the seller doesn't deliver.
- Silhouette 13y agoAs a user, you get your order confirmation and while it might take a bit longer for the money to arrive Setting up Direct Debits, at least the UK version, it's not "a bit longer" for your money to arrive, it's confirmation several days later vs. within seconds. For ongoing payments like subscriptions this probably isn't a huge deal, but for one-off payments it makes less sense. I much prefer debit, as it makes it much easier for me to get my money back if the seller doesn't deliver. Unfortunately from the seller's point of view, that also means it's much easier for someone to claim to be a customer, get hold of your e-book/music/software/whatever, and then reverse the payment. There are procedures for disputing chargebacks on credit cards, but with Direct Debit the guarantee is basically that banks will reverse first and ask questions later, and the time limits for doing so are much longer (if there are any at all). Again, this is less of a problem for ongoing payments for utility bills or something like SaaS where you can just cut off access if they stop paying, but for things like one-time downloads it's a huge risk for the merchant.
- raverbashing 13y agoI prefer not handling my bank account details for anything to anyone A credit card can be cancelled and purchases disputed.
- raverbashing 13y agoToo bad most stores have never heard about this "credit card thing", some will grudgingly accept EC (the german debit card)
- rbehrends 13y agoCredit card ownership in Germany was around 33% in 2011 [1]. The problem that credit cards have in Germany is that they have to compete with ELV (and soon SEPA Direct Debit, I suspect), which from a consumer's perspective (though not from a seller's) is the superior payment system (ease of chargebacks, plus the up to 150 Euro that you may have to eat if your credit card details are stolen, plus the historical tendency of the courts to side with banks over consumers in the case of card theft [2]). [1] http://www.bundesbank.de/Redaktion/EN/Downloads/Publications/Bulletins_and_surveys/payment_behaviour_in_germany_in_2011.pdf http://www.bundesbank.de/Redaktion/EN/Downloads/Publications... [2] The law has recently been changed to no longer make a prima facie assumption that you mishandled your PIN if your card was used fraudulently, but you may still have a lot of hassle to go through.
- wozniacki 13y agoReally? I'm certain they hate the notion of credit too which has long been attributed to their post-war mindset. Are other European notions similarly disposed towards credit (and thus credit cards), too?
- skrause 13y agoCredit card usage isn't low here because Germans hate credit, it's because we simply have had better alternatives for ages. Instead of credit cards people use Electronic cash (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_cash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_cash) in stores which is much cheaper for merchants, so they often don't even accept credit cards because of the fees. Online payments and payments of bills are usually done through direct withdrawals (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_debit#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_debit#Germany) with easy chargebacks.
- qznc 13y agoI always wondered why the US is so opposed to direct debit? It is so much easier and safer than credit cards or sending cheques by mail. The problem is that the rest of the world standardizes on credit cards. You cannot book a hotel or a conference without it. This is probably the only reason, why germans adopt credit cards: International travel.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoYou cannot book a hotel without a credit card? That's just incorrect.
- raverbashing 13y agoTechnically, you can. In practice, it's a different story. The reservation won't be guaranteed, that is, you have to be there before a certain hour for your guarantee to work. After that, if a customer walked in and asked for a room, sorry. Now try renting a car in the US without a credit card.
- 13y ago
- pc 13y agoCredit card usage is somewhat lower in Germany (though by a smaller margin than people think), and we considered holding off 'till we had a better answer to this. But we thought about it more, and talked to a bunch of German companies, and realized that a lot of German users want to sell to a global market in the very same way that, say, an American company would -- there isn't necessarily a tight coupling between the geography of your customers and the geography of your business. (This is what's great about the internet!) Travis CI is a good example here. Seen this way, we figured it made sense to bring the capabilities that US users have today to Germany as quickly as we could.
- Concours 13y agoThank you guys/girls, we have being waiting for this for a while now, we almost went with Paymill , so this is some awesome news. What's the issue with being able to accept Dollars only with a US Bank account, would you fix this after the beta or is it supposed to stay like this? ...or have I misunderstood something?
- k__ 13y agoHm yes, to sell stuff "from" Germany to the rest of the World this would be pretty nice :)
- WA 13y agoI just signed up for PayMill yesterday, but didn't send them the paperwork yet. I might as well sign up for Stripe then.
- danieldk 13y agoMaybe, but it's certainly not hard to get a credit card in Germany. I moved from The Netherlands to Germany on August 1 and I got a credit card with my bank account at no extra cost. A really big difference here however is that for daily groceries people tend to pay in cash and for lower amounts they'll refuse use of a debit card, while in The Netherlands practically everyone pays with a debit card all the time. It would be interesting to see per-country statistics.
- levosmetalo 13y agoIt has to do with privacy. Germans are quite fond of keeping up personal information personal, and they just don't want that bank can keep track of their purchases. That's the main reason why people here prefer cash as a method of payment. Of course, when paying or order something online, you need to provide your shipping address anyways, so credit cards brings at least a benefit of possible dispute if anything goes wrong.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoThat's one reason. Another one, for me, is that I'd feel bad about being too lazy to simply withdraw some cash from the ATM and carry it around with me. To me it's like walking around with an umbrella in light rain, refusing to eat a piece of bread that dropped on the ground, or the recentish plague of luggage with wheels. I consider it the hobbitification of humans, and I'm not playing. Then there is the fact that people who pay digitally tend to hold up the queue. Just plop down some cash and take the change, will ya. Gah.
- danieldk 13y agoAnother one, for me, is that I'd feel bad about being too lazy to simply withdraw some cash from the ATM and carry it around with me. It's the 21st century. I don't want to think about whether I should get 20 or 30 Euro from an ATM, let alone carry 100 Euro in my wallet. In fact, I find you reasoning quite weird: technology exists to make mundane and boring tasks unnecessary. Even worse is this 'digital wallet' that is required in some busses, etc., where you have to precharge the chip with a certain amount of money. Then there is the fact that people who pay digitally tend to hold up the queue. Just plop down some cash and take the change, will ya. Gah. That's because the checkout process in Germany is not optimized for bank card payments. Try to go to a Dutch supermarket (e.g. Albert Heijn in city centers) and it's usually cash payers who are slowing down the queues. Thank god, they have counters these days where they only allow bank cards.
- MrBuddyCasino 13y agoGermans pay by card all the time (I think you know them as debit cards?), we just don't use credit cards, because there is no advantage of doing so. Every "giro" account comes with one, and you can use it at the ATM and at the cash register. I think this is because historically, wire transfers between most banks in Germany have been easy and cheap for decades, while it is different in the US, as I understand it.
- superuser2 13y agoWire (instant) transfers from consumer US bank accounts typically carry a $25/transaction fee, and in some cases can only be initiated by phone or in person. Interestingly, Citi has a nice web interface for person-to-person ACH transfers (direct deposit), but it's not widely used and I don't think most other banks have it.
- MrBuddyCasino 13y agoWow, $25 per transaction is insane! So, just to make sure I don't get this wrong: in the US, most people can't login to their bank's website and transfer cash to someone else's account for free? Its usually not instantaneous (I think EC is, though), but rarely takes more than 1-2 days between different banks.
- superuser2 13y agoCitibank's web interface is integrated with PopMoney which lets me send large transfers via ACH (3 days) or smaller overnight transfers to accounts I've interacted with before. I think some of the other large corporate banks have this. I've never heard of anyone using it. My dad works in the financial services sector and was stunned that such a thing even existed. It would be impractical to use this for most payments because the recipient has no indication that the transaction is actually going to take place until at least the next business day. When individuals buy from merchants in the US, they almost always use a MasterCard or Visa (sometimes attached to a checking account, sometimes to a line of credit) via magnetic swipe or by typing the number. Individuals settle with each other individuals (tutoring, babysitting, reimbursing tickets, etc) using paper checks or cash. I believe there are some startups targeting person-to-person payments, but most involve transaction fees and/or or creating an account with your banking details, neither of which anyone wants.
- marijn 13y agoThat's not quite accurate, as other comments pointed out. But even if no German resident ever used a credit card, the significance of this is that German-based merchants can start using Stripe to accept Internet payments from people all over the world.
- LinXitoW 13y agoI'm German, and can confirm two things: - Almost anyone that would be able to actually use a credit card online has a credit card - Everyone i know dislikes credit cards, including me. They still have the correct stigma of paying with money you don't have and causing a housing crisis because of it; they're "american" and very "capitalist".
- cmarschner 13y agoCredit cards in Germany are for the most part debit cards. You only pay an annual fee and the charges are deducted from your bank account at the end of the month. No credit involved apart from the late processing. There are some special laws in place for this I think which don't exist in other countries. On the other hand merchants pay a hefty fee for each transaction whereas EC/debit card fees are very low. That's why many merchants (especially outside tourist areas) don't accept CCs.