7 ms·
Diaspora celebrates one year as a community project
- Groxx 13y agoI've been letting my keep-up-with-it-iveness slide on Diaspora. Anyone know how it has been doing recently? It still mostly never comes up in my news, which isn't a great sign, but I gather it's still moving along reasonably well.
- dodyg 13y agoGood on them. It must be nice to be able to work outside the spotlight and the astronomical expectation.
- singingfish 13y agoWhat shits me is that Diaspora shouldn't have started as a software project. It should have started as a bunch of RFCs. I tried to get a student project up a couple of years ago suggesting to produce said RFCs, but I got no bites.
- dasil003 13y agoFresh-faced college kids don't know how to write RFCs. Building something was the only way for them to iterate and learn.
- beagle3 13y agoEvery successful RFC in the past started life as a description of an existing implementation. Starting wih an RFC is the wrong way around
- singingfish 13y agoyeah, but you do a roughish prototype then write an RFC.
- beagle3 13y agoDiaspora after 6-9 months was nothing more than a roughish prototype. (One might claim it still is)
- singingfish 13y agothen they should write down the spec. The correct solution to disparate facebook is the same class of problem as IMAP, SMTP, HTTP, Jabber etc.
- dvt 13y agoAlthough this is pretty neat, I can't help but feel that Diaspora could have been so much more. Not only did they receive significant media coverage, but we shouldn't forget the $200k+ they got from their crowdfunding campaigns. I'm not one to bash on starving student start-ups (I'm guilty of the same starry-eyed naivete), but I can't help but feel a bit cynical about the Diaspora situation. They had a chance (a real chance) and they blew it. And in some ways, I feel that if they would have succeeded, we wouldn't still have to be using Facebook or G+ or what-have-you: that is, services that go out of their way to breach privacy in every way imaginable. I'm not an anti-NSA Free Softare Foundation e-hippie fanatic (let's be fair: there's a ton on HN), but there is a very real and very dangerous loss of privacy when using for-profit services like Facebook to store a significant portion of very sensitive and private information. So I'm not worried about the NSA as much as I'm worried about Facebook or Google circumventing ethical principles in lieu of targeted advertising, using my face/name without my consent, backing up private data when I want it deleted, etc. Diaspora could have been a solution, but it failed. In a very real sense, it failed us all. So every time I read about Disapora, I can't help but let out a sad sigh. I wish I didn't have to use Facebook. I really do. I wish I had a chance ($200k and a free trip to the Bay sounds nice) to disrupt the social media sphere; but alas, I do not. Diaspora did; and now, years down the road, it hasn't even reached a 500k user base[0]. [0] https://diasp.eu/stats https://diasp.eu/stats
- colmvp 13y ago200k is not a lot of money, especially when competing against a multi-billion dollar company that has had a number of years head start. Furthermore, the advantage the project provided was never really clear from a laymen's perspective. My bias belief is that most people don't love Facebook but don't have a necessary reason to move elsewhere especially when a social network relies on ones social network. IMO, G+ has a prettier UI and some cooler features. But while a lot of my network has joined, few have used it again after launch. Ultimately if they were to have done it again years back, I think it would've been interesting to do a pure mobile social networking app. Again bias perspective, but I've noticed most of my online interactions with friends nowadays isn't through Facebook, e-mail, or Twitter, but through Whatsapp, Snapchat, Instagram (yes, I know Facebook bought them) and Vine.
- abskhn 13y agoSomething that might be of interest to this community: https://register.blib.us https://register.blib.us : We have been working on it for a couple of years now. Someday in the near future, we plan to go open source, but haven't taken the plunge yet.
- bsaul 13y agoThe problem with decentralized social networks is not a software one but a hosting one. Where do i want to put my data ? It should be somewhere alwas connected, with backups and huge storage amount. In my opinion it could only be at internet access provider and simply be an extension of email (a bit like what wave wanted to do). Imho the problem is mostly political at those companies.
- sambarino 13y agoi'm not sure how much of an influencing factor it was to the project as a whole, but from my own experience I think their choice of using RoR prevented a lot of developers from joining in. compare this: npm install diaspora to this: https://wiki.diasporafoundation.org/Installation/Ubuntu/Raring https://wiki.diasporafoundation.org/Installation/Ubuntu/Rari...
- josteink 13y agoNode didn't even exist when they started out. At least not in anything which resembled production quality. And trying to "install" node on Ubuntu or other Debian-based distros for a long time required getting entire Chrome/V8 to build, from source. Something which was near impossible to setup, unless extremely dedicated. I tried twice and failed. Your "npm install diaspora" came with a 20page+ distro-wrecking set of instructions for configuring your build-machine. And if you failed, you woiuld probably have to re-install your distro because of the mess you made. Those "horrible instructions" listed there look extremely friendly in comparison. They may have done lots of things wrong, but chosing RoR over Node was not one of them.
- sambarino 13y agoyeah, I'm not saying they should have used node. just that their choice of tech did create a barrier to entry. they could have used something like php if they wanted to make it easy for people to get on board and dev.
- keywonc 13y agoAnybody backed this project in 2010? I'm curious what the backers think of the outcome so far.
- rogerbraun 13y agoI think that in the case of Diaspora, you really have to be the change you want to see. I canceled my Facebook account, joined a Diaspora pod and invited all my friends with a long explanatory email for why I did this. None of them canceled their FB-Account, but they all joined Diaspora. Change is possible, but it will not happen if we all do nothing and wish someone else would have done something.
- anywherenotes 13y agoAre they using Diaspora, beyond the joining part? If they want to post an update or a picture, do they post in both Facebook and Diaspora? I would imagine some active users post on both, and most users would just use Facebook. So the users of both will be annoyed to get double updates for some people. The users of one of them will wonder why the other friend knows more about their mutual friend. I can't see getting into Facebook space as a good thing. For example Twitter seems to have a different space, Instagram also seems different.
- dspillett 13y agoThe key thing that I and a bunch of my technical contacts were interested in was the portability between pods, which if I remember rightly was intended to allow a user to download their content and import it into an account on another pod. This would mean we could keep our own individual backups so if something went terribly wrong with where-ever the current data was hosted it would be easy to move to another pod. This feature was down as "coming soon!" for a long time, but as far as I can see having had a quick look at the site for the first time in months, and that feature doesn't seem to be mentioned at all now. This is a key problem for projects like this: many people who are interested in a particular aspect won't touch the project until that aspect is mature, or at least present, because if it isn't there already it might never turn up as project priorities changes (OK; so existing features can vanish over time for similar reasons, but this is much more rare). EDIT: Just found mention of the above feature buried in the FAQ (it used to be on the front page or there-abouts), and it is now described as "in the future" not "coming soon" so I shall not hold my breath. Going by that document the "export all your data" half of the feature is present though, which would at least satiate my paranoid need to keep my own backups of everything.
- captainbenises 13y agoDecentralized still means pods that the NSA can get a warrant for and access. The only real answer is a peer-to-peer social network. http://bennolan.com/2013/08/22/social-network-over-webrtc.html http://bennolan.com/2013/08/22/social-network-over-webrtc.ht...
- warcode 13y agoIf anything has ever been in need of a container like docker, it is Diaspora.
- danielsamuels 13y agoI'm surprised they don't use App.net as a base.