3 ms·
I can't help thinking that certain languages impose their own variation of the Blub syndrome, namely in leading to the conclusion that one particular way of thi
by ubernostrum 17y ago
I can't help thinking that certain languages impose their own variation of the Blub syndrome, namely in leading to the conclusion that one particular way of thinking about programming should be the One True Way to think about programming.
Various Lisps, for example, produce the well-known "when all you have is an AST, everything looks like a macro" syndrome; Scheme inculcates a desire to use tail recursion even when counting on one's fingers; etc.
This is, incidentally, precisely the same criticism proponents of functional programming typically level at proponents of, say, object-oriented programming. And I've no doubt that, if the popularities of those paradigms were reversed, comments like this one would be the usual snipe from OOP fans at their "unenlightened" functional brethren and sistren.
At any rate, I'm very far from being convinced that this is a healthy thing for either the programmers affected, or for the state of the art in general.
- halo 17y agoOn the other hand, you get complaints over the complexity of C++ because it doesn't really have 'One True Way' to do anything. Ultimately, it's a case of trade-offs, and accepting that can't win them all.
- j_baker 17y agoI agree 100%. While I would like to see macros, I think they're more in the "That would be so cool!" category than the "This is really necessary" category.
- rw 17y agoWhen you can modify the semantics of the entire language, you can use any paradigm you want.
- sethg 17y ago...which is great, until you want to use one paradigm and you also want to take advantage of a certain library, and you discover that the library uses a completely different paradigm. Either you put up with an impedence mismatch between your code and the library, or you discover that in this language all paradigms are equal but some are more equal than others.