3 ms·
It's not always under an individuals control. Things happen outside their control so they can't pay back their loan. In insurance, getting into an accident isn'
by Houshalter 13y ago
It's not always under an individuals control. Things happen outside their control so they can't pay back their loan. In insurance, getting into an accident isn't always the persons fault and we still use it to determine their rates.
Why should some predictors should be considered "sacred"? The point is to make the best predictions possible. It doesn't really matter what information is used to determine that.
- sliverstorm 13y agoWe aren't talking about vehicle insurance, which does allow the use of gender, age, and happenstance.
- Houshalter 13y agoIt's basically the same thing though.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIf we assume they are the same, then one is wrong. How do we know which one is wrong?
- Houshalter 13y agoI meant that risk prediction is insurance is very similar to risk prediction in loans. I'm not sure what you mean. What one is wrong?
- nitrogen 13y agoSome predictors must be sacred because relying on them reinforces divisions in society, leading to greater long-term unrest.
- Houshalter 13y ago>Some predictors must be sacred because relying on them reinforces divisions in society, leading to greater long-term unrest. Even using something objectionable like race as a predictor wouldn't "lead to long-term unrest", just the potential of slightly higher and lower interest rates for different individuals. There is no "reinforcing divisions in society". If anything more accurate predictions benefit society with less risk for investors and lower interest rates for borrowers.
- nitrogen 13y agoSociety isn't a one-shot system; it's iterative with feedback. When you apply a slight bias in interest rates to different parts of the population in one iteration, then feed those results into the next generation, those segments of the population paying slightly higher interest rates now have slightly less cash and slightly fewer opportunities. Repeat this for a few generations, and you have inescapable poverty on one hand and nearly unassailable wealth on the other.
- Houshalter 13y agoThere are far greater forces at work that determine how people end up than small differences in interest rates. In any case it's not my fault if some population is worse at paying back their loans, why should I have to subsidize them? Or why should others have to subsidize me?
- nitrogen 13y agoThe past is not your fault, but the future might be. The world will be an even more screwed up place if everyone takes your attitude and only cares about their own bottom line.
- Houshalter 13y agoThat's just not going to happen. Not because interest rate predictions becoming more accurate anyways.