2 ms·
1) You and I agree, no publisher who is capable of individually converting a user will sign up to use this. 2) You and I agree, you can get all the bennies o
by patio11 17y ago
1) You and I agree, no publisher who is capable of individually converting a user will sign up to use this.
2) You and I agree, you can get all the bennies of being a publisher without actually attempting to convert users. Put on tracking code, collect checks, yay.
3) You think the game theory equilibrium results in a healthy ecosystem of lots of publishers cooperating to make an Internet-wide Content Cartel which will use the awe-inspiring power of warm fuzzies to convert a sizable number of people into Contexture customers. (Incidentally: you seem to minimize the difference between the free and freemium experiences -- tiny upgrades and warm fuzzies. I think this is because you understand that there being significant differences in the experiences makes sites substantially LESS valuable to you. Do you understand that this this same dynamic gives every site an incentive to defect?)
4) I think the game-theory equilibrium is that nobody makes any attempt to convert users, a few dozen blogs nobody has ever heard of put the tracking code on their sites, some intense competition happens for cuts of fractions of $4.80 times a few dozen people, and a few months later the system dies for lack of interest.
Like I said on the last thread, there needs to be a Killer App site to build this ecosystem around, like eBay was the Killer App that every other Paypal merchant got to freeload off of. However, unlike the eBay/Paypal symbiot, in this case if you have the Killer App you should run screaming from this business proposition.
My, this would be a fascinating collective action problem for a game theory class...
But yeah:
All sites have an incentive to defect (not lock up a significant amount of value behind the paywall, not attempt to convert users in any significant fashion).
If no one puts value behind the paywall, then this idea is a more complicated implementation of the oldest failed business model, which is putting out a tip jar and hoping money falls into it. Money very rarely spontaneously falls into tip jars.
- gojomo 17y agoOnce the proto-cartel is bootstrapped by sites looking for 'pennies from heaven', it's completely up to Contenture's management how the incentives evolve. I think there's a fair chance the strategy-path can be engineered to be: (1) Publishers sign up as free riders. (2) The signup bonuses and other payoff tweaks from Contenture convince a few sites at the margin to push paid subscriptions and increase the functionality gradient between paid and unpaid visitors. (3) That provides enough variety and experimental information to keep iteratively optimizing conversion tactics -- where conversions are both turning unpaid users into subscribers, and turning publishers into better upsellers. A site that can manage its own subscriptions can 'defect' -- but just as with running your own ad sales, there are many, many more sites that just want a drop-in solution. However, the 'defection' you talk about -- shirking the shared task of creating/retaining paid subscriptions -- is subject to monetary incentives totally under Contenture's control. They design the 'black box' of payouts and can adjust the signup bonuses, the ratio of payouts for protected pageviews vs. free pageviews, and more. They can expel anyone blatantly gaming the system -- unless such gaming also benefits them. Eventually, if you're not carrying your weight, your check each month is just a token amount to remind you you could be doing more. It's a subscription-revenues mirror of AdSense in many ways, and they have enough levers to adjust there's a chance of finding a self-reinforcing formula.