3 ms·
It just occurred to me that the more benefits jobs provide, the more dependent on those jobs people become, and the harder they fall when they lose those jobs.
by enraged_camel 13y ago
It just occurred to me that the more benefits jobs provide, the more dependent on those jobs people become, and the harder they fall when they lose those jobs.
This is NOT an argument against providing benefits, of course. But it does create a weird dynamic.
- danielweber 13y agoPeople might be unable to leave because they need their current employer's health insurance, but not leaving because of losing disability? That's a new one.
- enraged_camel 13y agoI didn't say that. Reading comprehension is your friend.
- bcoates 13y agoCOBRA should fix the former, but it doesn't appear to cover the latter.
- tomjen3 13y agoPotentially stupid question, but wouldn't they be covered under their new employers insurance?
- Swannie 13y agoNot a stupid question. I am covered, during my time I am diagnosed with cancer. I get treatment, and am declared "free" of cancer. I remain that way for 5 years, and claim no more benefits. I am still covered. I leave, and join a new company. To enter their health insurance, I have to declare any "pre-existing" conditions. They see that I am in remission from cancer, and offer my employer two choices: pay hugely inflated premiums, or get no cover. My new employer never expected to need to cover premiums 20 times that of their existing employees, and consequently I am now screwed.
- toast0 13y agoMany times there is an exception for pre-existing conditions if you had continuous credible coverage.
- danielweber 13y agoThe "P" in HIPAA stands for "Portability." Group plans are limited in how long they can exclude someone for pre-existing conditions, and guarantees no waiting period if they already had qualifying insurance. The private market doesn't have the same protections, for reasons both good and bad.
- acdha 13y agoThis argument comes up frequently when people discuss startups: once it involves losing health coverage, a significant number of people lose interest in participating. The current system heavily encourages anyone with less than perfect health / dependents to work for a mid-to-large-sized company, to our relative disadvantage when compared with the rest of the first world.