2 ms·
On the one hand, I agree that these machines are unlikely to be a public health risk, and I further agree with you on the real problems here. On the other, I t
by wpietri 13y ago
On the one hand, I agree that these machines are unlikely to be a public health risk, and I further agree with you on the real problems here.
On the other, I think that that it's misleading to compare risks you choose with risks that are forced upon you. That's part of what has people up in arms here; it's clear that the TSA didn't really care about safety or privacy when they started with this, so I'm ok with people being deeply suspicious about the "no, really, it's all safe and private now" shtick.
Also, I think this is dangerous: "By analogy, you don't need to study the health effects of every single x-ray machine because we know what x-rays do. You just need to know the machine's dosage and wavelength."
It's worth considering the THERAC-25, a device with software bugs that killed 3 people: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25
There's always a difference between what a machine is supposed to do and what it actually does. None know that better than HNers. Given that this is a novel technology rushed into production using giant government contracts to satisfy the security theater apparatus, it's reasonable to worry whether corners were cut, worries suppressed, or facts buried.
I'm happy to trust my dentist's x-ray machine because he's a licensed, trained medical professional who's focused on healing, and who plans to stand right next to it for a couple decades. None of that applies in the TSA situation.
I think the TSA scanners are probably fine anyhow, and I've used them happily when I don't have time to be obstreperous. But I don't fault people who refuse to trust the TSA on this.