3 ms·
The reason so many in the media have had a viscerally negative reaction to Assange and Snowden is that they completely ignored this delicate back and forth, ski
by grey-area 13y ago
The reason so many in the media have had a viscerally negative reaction to Assange and Snowden is that they completely ignored this delicate back and forth, skipping straight to full scale publication. In essence, they did not follow the media establishment's rules for responsible journalistic disclosure.
That's not really true of Greenwald working with the Guardian, the Guardian editors have run each story past the authorities prior to publication, according to Alan Rusbridger and Janine Gibson. And the stories have been heavily redacted by them and Greenwald. I think they've been quite responsible, and Greenwald certainly has had editorial input from the Guardian, and is far from the only reporter there on this story, I think I've seen at least 10 other bylines. See this interview with Charlie Rose for details from the editors on their process:
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7pdzzZB7Xgo http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7pdzzZB7Xgo
I think it's more that the traditional press sense the end of an era and with it a huge erosion of their power and prestige - their monopoly on news is simply vanishing, and that creates some hostility to these upstarts who don't understand the rules of the game like Greenwald, wikileaks bloggers etc. and who are willing to completely forgo any access to government sources, and thus are in many ways more independent than the White House press pool.
It'll be great to see the nytimes running with this now that the guardian is giving them access, they did a really detailed synopsis of the story so far anchored on Laura Poitras recently which is really worth reading. I'm also really interested to see what she does with her film, perhaps it'll come out just in time for the elections!
- s_q_b 13y agoGood points, I hadn't realized how involved the Guardian's editors had been in Greenwald's recent stories, especially since he retained sole editorial control over his publications in the past. The way my friends in the journalistic world have explained it me was in terms of "breaking unwritten rules." The anti-leaker reaction seems very extreme for simple sour grapes, although I suppose it isn't wise to underestimate the reactionary posturing of an industry in decline. I have heard pretty detailed confirmation that the recent events at the Guardian have really altered the US press's attitude thus far. It's odd to me they didn't redact the program codenames. Since the codenames are legal to know, as long as you don't say the underlying program to which they refer, they're commonly plastered all over unclassified presentations. Once you know the underlying technology, the combination of codename and context gives away a lot of information. I've seen people spidering based upon the program names that were leaked so far. With a little bit of googling and clustering of results, they can figure out which programs relate to e.g. upstream collection. That seems like a bonanza for hostile intelligence agencies, especially since they can add all of those codenames to KWS, and wait until someone accidentally slips and describes them in an open channel.