5 ms·
This actually makes a lot of sense. A lot of articles have been talking about how there's no obvious candidate for new CEO, and that it's basically too much for
by crazygringo 13y ago
This actually makes a lot of sense. A lot of articles have been talking about how there's no obvious candidate for new CEO, and that it's basically too much for any single person to take on.
But if Microsoft were split into divisions (Windows/Mobile/Tablets, Enterprise/Office, Xbox/entertainment, Bing/Hotmail somewhere?) that could freely compete, it's actually pretty easy to imagine suitable CEO's for each one.
I'm truly hard-pressed to think of any value Microsoft as a conglomerate of these divisions, actually provides, strategy- or synergy-wise -- at least that's visible to those of us outside the company.
But is there any kind of precedent for this? It's common for companies to spin off a division, but I can't think of any company voluntarily truly breaking itself up like this. It's hard to imagine a board saying, "we admit we're not providing strategic value here, let's break ourselves up".
- sidww2 13y agoXbox/Bing/Hotmail might have a hard time staying afloat w/o the profits from Windows/Enterprise/Office.
- wicknicks 13y agoMaybe have a common pool of resources from which they draw from. That would force the "weaker" companies to compete more or pivot to create better products.
- astrodust 13y agoRemember that every division with the exception of Windows + Office has a hard time turning a consistent profit. XBox (independent) vs. Sony, Android and Apple is a losing proposition, they may as well sell the division. In a high-stakes game like that, you need a parent company with deep, deep pockets. Windows independent of Office is worthless. There's virtually no reason to use Windows apart from the Office infrastructure built around it, or the entrenched base Visual Studio developers. It's somewhat popular as a gaming platform, but as Linux starts to be reshaped into a first-class gaming operating system, that will quickly become a non-factor. The online division is the most troubled, basically a black-hole for money. Surely it could be made profitable, or simply sold for a massive chunk of cash to someone like Yahoo! who could afford to pick it up. It's not that the divisions would do better independently, but they're part of a highly dysfunctional family that cannot survive independently.
- Osiris 13y agoWhile a break-up into separate companies may not make sense, giving each product group more independence to act like a separate group may allow products to be more flexible and reactive to user demands.
- gutsy 13y agoThe average non-power user isn't going to want to learn how to use Linux, they're comfortable with Windows so they'll stick with Windows. I predict that they'll make two very distinct version of Windows next time, one for tablets like Windows 8 and one a lot more like Windows 7 for the desktops.
- astrodust 13y agoOS X is BSD based and you don't need to be a power user to learn how to use it. I'm not sure what your argument is here. With the right UX and application suite, Linux is for all intents and purposes just as functional as Windows is.
- gutsy 13y agoA mac is very expensive, that rules that out. I know Linux is just as functional as Windows is. Most people on this site know that, but we aren't the ones buying most PCs. Imagine your mom, dad, brother or sister who don't use computers like crazy trying to learn how to use Linux. If it's too different, "it doesn't work at all." Too many people are afraid to learn new things, which is sad.
- astrodust 13y agoI don't know about "very expensive" unless you're in the market for a bargain bin computer. A Mac Mini costs $599, an feature equivalent Dell is maybe $399 to $499, so there is a price premium but it's not outrageous. Plus, you do get significantly better support from the retailer, cheaper upgrade options on the operating system, and a lot of bundled apps that, for some people, are more than worth the extra dollars. It's not that people are not afraid to learn new things, they just have priorities, and often "learn a new OS" is not on their list. Remember, Linux has succeeded on Android, so don't think it's impossible for people to use it.
- devx 13y agoMaybe, but here's the thing. Splitting them like that might help the already rich ones (Windows and Office), while it would hurt the struggling ones (Xbox, Bing, Surface). I actually don't know how Xbox is doing financially on its own these days, but I doubt it's extremely profitable and has a lot of cash on its own. The consoles usually make the money back over certain period of time from games. Could Xbox survive on its own in that scenario? As for Bing - it's still losing billions of dollars a year last I checked. So are the Surface tablets, and Skype - well Microsoft paid over $8 billion for Skype, and they're not going to get that money back anytime soon. Hotmail, despite many registered accounts, was pretty dead, and I think only some transitioned to Outlook.com.
- freehunter 13y agoIt seems to me like high end gaming consoles are unsustainable anyway. Sony could barely keep Playstation alive if it wasn't sinking money into the product that it had gained from other sales. Microsoft is in the same boat. Apple and Google's "gaming" division is just co-opted from their existing hardware and don't take significant resources to run. Nintendo is the only company able to keep itself afloat just from console hardware and software, and we see the market it competes in. It seems no one is willing to go toe-to-toe with Nintendo on their home turf.
- ant512 13y ago"As for Bing - it's still losing billions of dollars a year last I checked." Allowing the successful divisions to survive and the leeches to die seems like a win for MS. Why is throwing away billions on products that produce no return a good thing?
- freehunter 13y agoThere's the concept of a loss leader: you lose money on one product because it gains the company money when the consumer buys another product. Remember that the Xbox lost billions year over year for 8 years until it was profitable. Microsoft has repeatedly shown us that they're playing the long game. If they're predicted to make money even a decade from now, they'll keep posting losses until that point comes (Xbox). If they're predicting a failure, they'll very unceremoniously pull the product (Kin/Zune). To steal a line from Breaking Bad, they're not in the software business. They're in the empire business.
- dermotbrennan 13y agoI think there's some value in the goal of having a common interface and set of features across desktop, mobile, xbox, server. People would like that. Microsoft haven't achieved that there yet but it's still a worthy goal. I think slimming down and refocusing might be more effective than a massive break-up.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- auctiontheory 13y agoI'm truly hard-pressed to think of any value Microsoft as a conglomerate of these divisions, actually provides You must not be an enterprise IT buyer. Here's how it works: All large corporations use some Microsoft product, be it Windows, Exchange, Office, or something else. And they get volume discounts and significant other discounts off the list price. "Oh, you want to replace Office with OpenOffice? Hmmm, seems we made a mistake calculating your Exchange licenses - the price just went up 300%." Is it becoming more clear?
- mbreese 13y agoIsn't that how they got in trouble last time? That's hardly a value for the consumer. (I know that's not what happened before, but it's still anti-competitive)
- auctiontheory 13y agoIt's not a value to the consumer. It's an albatross to the consumer. It's a value provided to the bottom line of each of the MSFT divisions from/by the existence of the unified Microsoft corporate entity.