3 ms·
> The last is not really practical That's true. But applying stack ranking to small groups because applying it to large groups is impractical is kind of like
by lisper 13y ago
> The last is not really practical
That's true. But applying stack ranking to small groups because applying it to large groups is impractical is kind of like looking for your lost keys under the street light because it's too dark to look where you actually lost them.
> "in a department of 500 engineers", it's likely that at least 5 are duds.
That's true too. The problem is this reasoning does not scale downwards. Its correctness DEPENDS on the number being large. What MS is doing is saying: "In 50 groups of 10 engineers, at least 2 engineers IN EACH GROUP MUST BE DUDS" and that is NOT true. But because policy dictates that the company will behave as if it were true it produces very strong pressure on people to spend their time making it appear to be true rather than doing productive work.