3 ms·
If "paleo" concepts apply to food, why not thinking? Its very interesting that we've existed as thinking animals for a lot longer than "office jobs" have exist
by VLM 13y ago
If "paleo" concepts apply to food, why not thinking?
Its very interesting that we've existed as thinking animals for a lot longer than "office jobs" have existed.
From an evolutionary perspective, our best thinking was almost certainly done in near perfect silence or at most calm animal noises. Hmm, we're tracking that yummy large mammal and I'm hungry, whats the next move? So I hear my neighbor chipping away quietly as I think up the best way to whack this rock to make it a better arrowhead. How do I cut this tree down so it doesn't land on my head? So I'm staring at these wheat seeds, thinking about what would happen if I buried them in the dirt and came back later. So looking at the position of the sun / moon / stars, is this the time to plant the wheat seeds?
I don't see an evolutionary example of hard successful thinking in an intentionally noisy distracting environment. In fact if its noisy its because the lion is roaring at us trying to eat us, so deep thinking is probably not advised compared to fight or flight. I guess fight or flight style coding exists at places swirling the drain. Finish this report or we're all on the unemployment line next week. Um, OK, crank up the death metal on the speakers and see ya in twelve hours with a finished product ...
From an evolutionary standpoint we should be able to do our best, deepest thinking/coding on a bench at the zoo by the "food" animals, or perhaps sitting in a cow pasture. In (rare) good weather, I've had decent results with a laptop sitting in a covered (dark-ish) park rain shelter.
- dllthomas 13y agoI'm not sure your examples of our most demanding thinking are accurate. Mightn't those historically have been social? In which case voices might very well have been part of the environment.
- VLM 13y agoNo, silence is vital for hunting. Also if a possible mate or friend is talking to you, its not exactly helpful to be daydreaming about growing seeds or moon phases. If you're doing hard manual labor while visualizing a simpler way to do it, you're probably breathing too hard to talk. I will give you credit that sometimes ancient humans probably had to think pretty hard while talking. Planning a hunt. Trying to organize sleeping arrangements. Primitive military operation planning beyond the level of a crude bar fight (so they basically stole one of our proto-cows, can we take them and how?) (I should edit this to remove the second paragraph, upon contemplation, that's not thinking while talking, thats concentrating hard on listening to the other person in order to plan how to manipulate them, which is at cross purposes to writing great code or daydreaming as the original topic... We've had strong evolutionary pressure to think very hard about verbal language we hear, which isn't going to help much when I'm trying to debug something while some sports water cooler conversation is going on)
- dllthomas 13y agoI didn't mean that the hunts were social, but that hunts might not present as large a cognitive challenge as social dynamics. Otherwise, I basically agree, I think - it does seem likely that the drain on attention would outweigh whatever other benefits - I'm just saying it's not clear that we'd get an extra cognitive boost from silence just because it's silence for evolutionary reasons.
- asdasf 13y ago>If "paleo" concepts apply to food There is no evidence that they do.
- VLM 13y agoThat doesn't even make sense. Other than a "god created us this way to test our faith, not evolution" or some similar argument. You'd have to elaborate. WRT "paleo" I'm talking specifically about applying the same anatomical/digestive/biochemical analysis that works pretty well with any other animal to figure out ideal foods and such. Not "paleo" as a large scale social movement, or as a podcasting/blogging/social media trend subject, which is not as directly evolutionarily relevant. For example, if you dissect a cow its not hard to figure out its should kick butt WRT eating raw fresh grass. Or dissect a cat and its not hard to figure out its "supposed" to eat mice and mouse size (or smaller) animals. People? Obviously mostly carnivore by design, omnivore as a suboptimal backup plan, although given our horrible ability with vitamin C and such, we're obviously better off eating "some" citrus fruit on a regular basis or other source of vitamin C. Vitamin B retention is legendarily bad too, we're supposed to eat lots of stuff promoting vit B. On the other hand take it easy with sources of vit A and D our innards handle that even worse than wheat and corn. The analogy is we've been thinking for a long time in vaguely known environments. The evolutionarily "new" environment of offices and desk jobs has the responsibility of explaining why they need special rules different than the past. What made our ancestors successful is probably a good starting point.
- asdasf 13y ago>WRT "paleo" I'm talking specifically about applying the same anatomical/digestive/biochemical analysis that works pretty well with any other animal That has nothing to do with paleo, so forgive me for not guessing that. Paleo specifically means the time period before recorded human history. Dissecting a cow has absolutely nothing to do with paleo anything. Paleo is commonly used as a short hand for http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleolithic_diet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleolithic_diet which is the naturalistic fallacy applied to modern human behavior. It is not supported by evidence.