3 ms·
Historical context is always needed when one looks at something like this: The US relationship with Iraq & Iran was very complex. In 1979 the Iranian revoluti
by nl 13y ago
Historical context is always needed when one looks at something like this:
The US relationship with Iraq & Iran was very complex.
In 1979 the Iranian revolution occurred, which humiliated the US.
In 1982 the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan (which borders Iran). That was significant because it let the USSR threaten US oil interests in the Persian Gulf, and put the USSR one step closer to getting a sea port in the Arabian Sea and/or Indian Ocean.
Meanwhile, Saddam Hussein was continuing to threaten the US's ally Israel but was also smart enough to play the US off against the USSR.
Hussein was very worried about Iran because of the large number of Shia Moslems in Iraq.
When Iraq invaded Iran the US expected Iraq to win quickly, because the Iranians had very few advanced weapons. The US certainly didn't want Iran to win, but nor did they want Iraq to become more powerful in the region.
So the US (with Israeli help) began arming Iran (on a small scale). This is known as the Iran/Contra affair.
Thing went Iraq's way for a while, but eventually the Iranians began to push them back using "human wave attacks".
At this point the US began to fear that Iraq would actually lose, so they started giving Hussein financial and military support.
This is when the Iraqis resorted to gas: (unsurprisingly) they found it was very effective at breaking up the Iranian infantry charges.
There's little doubt that the US knew this would happen.
The interesting thing is that the fact Hussein used gas put a new perspective on the Israeli bombing of the Iraqi nuclear program (in 1981, towards the start of the Iran/Iraq war). While that was condemned at the time, when the knowledge of gas attacks became wide spread few people doubted that Hussein would have used a nuclear bomb as well if he had access to one.
Anyway.. a long history lesson.
I guess my question is "What should the US have done"?
- jacquesm 13y agoIt goes much further back than that. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Mossadeq http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Mossadeq And if you want you can go back all the way to the 1920's. What the US and the UK should have done is to let the Iranians govern their own country when it mattered. So much for exporting democracy.
- Create 13y agoBe more like postwar (West) Germany,
- nl 13y agoErr? Downvotes? I agree the story goes back further, but I can't write all of Wikipedia. I think what I wrote is a reasonably factual account that supplies reasonable context.
- jacquesm 13y agoAgreed. silly downvotes. Thanks for the summary! I do think that the Mossadeq affair should have been an integral part of the whole.
- nl 13y agoPerhaps. Ironically I have previously raised the Iran coup on HN, but someone appeared to disagree that it was sponsored by the CIA (this was prior to the release of documents proving it though): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5779374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5779374
- jacquesm 13y agoWow. That's pretty ignorant. I didn't even think anybody would still try to support that side of the issue, the horse was beaten to death and buried long ago. Trying to revive it likely won't work :)