4 ms·
I think you are missing the point. If a government wants to seize a property using it's eminent domain powers it has to pay "just compensation" for that propert
by bradleyjg 13y ago
I think you are missing the point. If a government wants to seize a property using it's eminent domain powers it has to pay "just compensation" for that property. The Supreme Court has interpreted that to mean fair market value.
If there was a CDO pool that included only mortgages based on houses in that particular town, perhaps the whole pool could be seized at once, based on the fair market value of all tranches of the CDO (although there might be tricky jurisdictional issues). However, that's not the case. The mortgages are spread across many many different such pools. So rather than one big eminent domain case, there needs to be a condemnation of each and every mortgage separately. That being the case, the city must pay the fair market value of each mortgage -- not the the FMV of an abstract average house.
The single biggest problem with the city's proposal is not that it is underpaying (though it likely is in most cases) but rather that it is trying to claim that every mortgage can be fairly valued using the same simple formula: 80% assessed value of the underlying asset. Simply put, that's nuts.
The second biggest problem is that Freddie and Frannie have already said that they won't refinance the written down mortgages. So the city would have to hold the mortgages to maturity. They don't seem to have anywhere near enough capital to do that, and I don't think the muni market would be terribly interested in financing such a scheme (or the litigation!). Especially not with Detroit making everyone nervous to begin with.
- mbreese 13y agoNo, I'm not missing the point. I'm trying to figure out their logic here. Which, I believe would be that they are trying to pay "just compensation" for a mortgage, based on the actual value of the house, and a built-in discount. The question is: is this a fair estimate of "just compensation". And it just might be, if you look at the mortgages in aggregate. It is harder to argue with an individual home, but when the entirety of all homes underwater is taken into account, that has a known risk associated with it. Each mortgage is different at the individual level, and so the risk would be harder to include in a discounted price. But when you lump them all together, you can start to look at how the risk affects the entire group, so you could start to apply the risk discount across the board. Some will be more risky, and others less. At least, that would be an arguable theory...
- bradleyjg 13y agoIf you want to know what they are thinking, check out Robert Hockett on SSRN. He's the intellectual force behind the whole idea.