4 ms·
Except that the US apparently has a specific treaty with the UN that says that the US will NOT spy on the UN headquarters on their soil...
by mpweiher 13y ago
Except that the US apparently has a specific treaty with the UN that says that the US will NOT spy on the UN headquarters on their soil...
- rayiner 13y agoLet the U.N. enforce it then.
- zxcdw 13y agoNo, instead of expect others to deal with the US foreign policy when it comes to spying, fix the offending foreign policy. US is at the blame here, not UN or those which US spies upon.
- rayiner 13y agoIt was a joke, to point out how ridiculous it is to talk about "treaties" with the U.N., which is not an entity that can enforce anything against the U.S. Not when the U.S. is a permanent member of the security council and provides 22% of the U.N.'s budget: http://globalsolutions.org/united-nations/funding http://globalsolutions.org/united-nations/funding. A "treaty" or "law" that can't be enforced doesn't merit the name--it's just lip service.
- ferdo 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfidious_Albion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfidious_Albion
- gruseom 13y agoWhat international agent has the power to enforce anything on the U.S.? Clearly none. So it follows from what you're saying that the U.S. doesn't have any treaty obligations at all. I thought even the hardest-nosed realists didn't argue that. Maybe neocons do?
- solnyshok 13y agoRemember where Snowden went for shelter? Obviously his job taught him, that the only 2 countries that USA cannot enforce anything on, are Russia and China.
- jacquesm 13y agoEssentially you are saying 'fuck you' to any other country but the US short of engaging in war. Do you realize that treaties exist with the express purpose of avoiding that? The fact that the US can bully its way wherever it wants and can afford to ignore every treaty it is signatory to is setting a fine example. I'd hold a tinpot dictator to a higher standard than this. It is recognized that some parties are stronger than others. That does not give the stronger parties the right to ignore their treaties, which count as solemn promises rather than lip-service. Dumb shit like this is what got us into plenty of wars in the past. If the United States does not want to be party to treaties then it should simply not sign them. (See: the ICC).
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago>If the United States does not want to be party to treaties then it should simply not sign them. That naivete ignores the fact that from a thug's perspective, it is entirely advantageous to sign treaties, and then secretly ignore them.
- jacquesm 13y agoSure, but on that note we might as well ignore any treaty and just disband the UN. I think a forum where nation states can gather in relative peace is a good thing and I think that nation states once bound by treaty should abide by that treaty, even the largest, especially the largest.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago>I think a forum where nation states can gather in relative peace is a good thing. Of course, I agree, but I'm not sure it can exist. >I think that nation states once bound by treaty should abide by that treaty, even the largest, especially the largest. Well, the US has demonstrated that it is not to be trusted. Move the UN HQ to... umm... I don't know where.
- jacquesm 13y ago
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago'Because Fuck You, that's why' works as a foreign policy when we're the biggest 800 pound gorilla in town. But it could turn out pretty badly for us (the US) later.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's not just being the biggest 800 pound gorilla, but also, through NATO, subsidizing the national defenses of the major European powers.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoI bet they could survive, and it worked better when the major European powers had a big scary USSR to fear. Now? Europe fears winter-time natural gas shortages (still a Russia problem, but a much nicer one to have), and gets some oil price benefit out of our mid-east intervention, but we take the lion's share so I'm not sure that subsidy means as much as we need it to.
- MichaelGG 13y agoIt would be interesting to see the fallout, though. How seriously are other countries going to take things? Could they apply sanctions against the US? Enough to get companies to effectively lobby against spying?
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago>It would be interesting to see the fallout, We're so smugly confident of the security of our position at the top of the heap that we can bemuse idly about how interesting it will be to watch foreign affairs in the near future. BTW, I'm not trying to mock you, any more than I mock myself for the same thoughts. But it worries me that so few people seem to even consider the possibility that our prospects for the future might be anything other than world dominance. >How seriously are other countries going to take things? Diplomats from the countries involved have known or been aware to some degree, but now they can publicly rebuke US/NATO policy initiatives. For that matter, anyone may now criticize UN policy on the basis that it lacks independence. >Could they apply sanctions against the US? Well, maybe not through UN resolution! But, sure; it may not have an effect if it isn't unilateral to some degree. The US still holds a lot of cards in that respect, but fewer each day it seems. When, (not if) consensus turns against the US, it will turn quickly. >Enough to get companies to effectively lobby against spying? The pessimist in me thinks that by the time public opinion in the US (even among the businessmen you're referring to) turns against gov't policy, the damage will already have been done. Arguably/Possibly a good thing for the world.