4 ms·
While there have been some good points brought up here, I think the author misunderstands what the purpose of Facebook is. Facebook is not in the same category
by adambratt 13y ago
While there have been some good points brought up here, I think the author misunderstands what the purpose of Facebook is.
Facebook is not in the same category as Reddit. Social network used to be a very specific category of website, now almost every consumer facing website is a social network. Reddit is a content creation and discussion community, basically a centralized version of the forums and bulletin boards of yesteryear. Facebook is a photo, link, and life sharing network.
If I'm sharing pictures of my family and friends, I'm giving up anonymity by default. The whole point of Facebook is to give an online pin board of what is going on in my life, who I am as a person, and what I think and I enjoy. It's the online identity of my human self.
Reddit is an open platform for all types of discussion and interaction at a macro scale. What happens on Reddit will rarely if ever affect my actual day to day life. The phrase "hive mind" is all too true when you consider the mass amount of meaningless content there is. It's the brain vomit of millions of people and that's what makes it awesome and interesting. For every thought or idea I have, I can find someone else who agrees with me and someone who doesn't.
Saying Facebook should learn from Reddit doesn't make much sense to me. Reddit not a new concept or idea. Historically, social interaction online had always been "anonymous" in one form or another. Facebook was the first truly successful community that did away with usernames and forced people to use their real names. To get a billion people to do that is an incredible feat.
In my humble opinion, Reddit is not revolutionary at all. The "moat" around the site/business is not near as big as Facebooks. All it would take for a Reddit killer to emerge is for a site to hit critical mass in terms of content and provide a better more targeted form of curation to the user than subreddits and karma. In contrary, Facebook has built a massive moat. Your friend list, your photo history, your about page, your Facebook connected sites and apps...this is a huge fucking moat. I'm not saying it would be easy for a Reddit killer to surface, I'm just pointing out that it's more likely than a Facebook killer.
I think it's important for us to recognize that Reddit's social network is not Twitter's social network which is not Facebook's social network and to understand this when making comparisons between them.
- baq 13y ago> In my humble opinion, Reddit is not revolutionary at all. This a thousand times. Reddit is a more user friendly, server-side usenet without most of its hard to grasp features (but with css, which actually matters way more than it seems with all those content: tricks.) PS. I was on usenet for a couple of years, then slashdot, then reddit, then here. Nothing of substance changed except a few abbreviations.
- criley2 13y agoIt's funny watching people poo-poo other's successes. Spoiler: if you think reddit isn't revolutionary, or doesn't have a big moat... put your skills where your mouth is and make something better and more successful. "All it takes to beat reddit is..." really? Really? It's easy for a layman to stand there and call reddit non-revolutionary. (Note: I call you a layman because you can't even write the business name 'reddit' correctly... Yeah I bet your an expert on the business ;) ) We're all waiting for the reddit killer. Been waiting almost a decade. Digg didn't last this long, and slashdot was never on top for this long. Social networks turned over quickly until facebook, and link aggregators turned over quickly until reddit. It's easy to downplay someone else's achievement without being able to replicate it or beat it yourself. Illusory superiority. I bet the people with huge experience in reddit's field will be much more hesitant to downplay it.
- AH4oFVbPT4f8 13y agoWhy can't Facebook be both? Ability to easily connect and find people on a personal level but also have the ability to have personas?