3 ms·
The link to the original WaPo report has been obscured in the OP, but it's worth reading to get a full understanding of this case http://www.washingtonpost.com
by danso 13y ago
The link to the original WaPo report has been obscured in the OP, but it's worth reading to get a full understanding of this case
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/08/19/obama-administration-asks-supreme-court-to-allow-warrantless-cellphone-searches/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/08/19...
> In 2007, the police arrested a Massachusetts man who appeared to be selling crack cocaine from his car. The cops seized his cellphone and noticed that it was receiving calls from “My House.” They opened the phone to determine the number for “My House.” That led them to the man’s home, where the police found drugs, cash and guns.
It's not quite the easy jump to declare that this case would open the gates to warrantless domestic phone surveillance. The defendant was arrested first. The WP post doesn't say if the police needed a warrant to get into the house or if the call represented "probable cause"
Also worth noting: the phone in this case was a dumb phone
- rainsford 13y agoThe government's argument in this case seems fairly reasonable. Conducting an in-person search of a cellphone after the suspect has been arrested seems similar to going through a bag they're carrying. The WaPo article argues that the storage capacity of modern cellphones should make them legally different (even though the phone in this case was a dumb phone), but I'm not sure how such a legal standard would work. I suppose one approach would be for police to be able to search things physically on the phone (like contact lists) but not things that the phone simply gives them access to (like email, social networks, bank info, etc). The problem with a smartphone is not so much that it contains a ton of info, but that it serves as an access point to a lot of personal info that would otherwise require a warrant to obtain. Maybe the legal analogy would be that police can't search your house without a warrant after they arrest you even if you have your house keys on you at the time. They can search your belongings but can't use those belongings (like keys) to conduct further warrantless searches.
- Amadou 13y agoThe problem with a smartphone is not so much that it contains a ton of info, but that it serves as an access point to a lot of personal info The current situation may very well change. It is entirely possible that much of that information stored "in the cloud" will migrate to being stored directly on people's phones. Facebook owes the majority of its popularity to being a place that easily hosts and shares photos. The continuing increases in wireless bandwidth and physical storage available on phones coupled with the growing understanding of the security risks of giving personal data to 3rd parties means that paradigm could shift quite easily.
- betterunix 13y agoThe problem here is that the police can find reasons to arrest a person. So, let's say you are a political dissident and the government wants to know when the next meeting of your protest group is. The police follow you around for an hour, pull you over for failing to come to a complete stop before a right turn on red, then arrest you for "disorderly conduct" and "resisting arrest." Now they search your phone, get the information they want, and release you, only to arrest you again next Sunday while you are making protest signs with your friends.