I disagree. Pseudonyms have in no way hindered polite, serious discussions on any forum I've ever seen. The only way to ensure the atmosphere you seek is throu

I disagree. Pseudonyms have in no way hindered polite, serious discussions on any forum I've ever seen. The only way to ensure the atmosphere you seek is through curated and carefully moderated discourse. Heavy or light-handedness in handling discussion will kill the atmosphere and dissuade any honesty, politeness or even truth (for fear of reprisal) even if real names are enforced. Reddit is the way it is because its founders and moderators wish it so. Every community gets the users it deserves. Edit: Some cleanups (not enough coffee... also it's 5:13AM here)