2 ms·
Yours is a fair enough argument, but I find the line you're drawing to be arbitrary. We can conceive of a continuum of security mechanisms, each with a given st
by baddox 13y ago
Yours is a fair enough argument, but I find the line you're drawing to be arbitrary. We can conceive of a continuum of security mechanisms, each with a given strength which can thwart attackers with a given skill level. For example, near one end of the continuum, minimizing the browser when I leave should thwart a computer-illiterate attacker. Somewhere between that end and your suggestion of a master password is Chrome's behavior, where the attacker must know that they can find your passwords in the browser settings. Near the other end might be biometric authentication, or even no option to save passwords at all.
A more sufficient version of your argument would attempt to show why the master password is an appropriate place to draw the line on this continuum, perhaps by arguing that it's an optimal balance between minimizing the valid user's frustration and thwarting some percentage of attackers.
- ronaldx 13y agoYes, there is a continuum of security, agreed. The correct place to draw the line is a place where the user has every convenience they want, and an attacker does not have any additional convenience. Revealing plaintext passwords does not convenience the user but it would convenience attackers (with low skill).
- jtheory 13y ago> Revealing plaintext passwords does not convenience the user That bit is not true, with a caveat. I have a ton of low-security username/password pairs stored in FF. I find I do need to look at the plaintext passwords now & again, because I want to open one of those sites on my phone, for example, and don't remember the password (I looked up my HN password just yesterday so I could sign in on my phone, actually). Sometimes I find I've saved multiple pairs for one site, and I need to review the passwords to figure out which is valid. I've used the same feature in Thunderbird with IMAP and SMTP server passwords, when I have an email account I've been using for year w/o changing the password, and I realize I haven't saved it anywhere else. All of these are not hampered by requiring a master password, of course... I'm in agreement with timbl on his reasons not to allow just anyone to view these by default.
- baddox 13y agoBut requiring a master password certainly does inconvenience the user.