3 ms·
Interesting. So the more you can affirm the views of the judges, the more likely you are to win. If you pique the interest or curiosity of the judges, the mor
by stcredzero 18y ago
Interesting. So the more you can affirm the views of the judges, the more likely you are to win. If you pique the interest or curiosity of the judges, the more likely you are to lose. That's disturbing. To me that's the stance the least likely to get at the truth.
I wonder if there's a highly intelligent and advanced alien civilization out there that would view our adversarial judicial system a mere refinement on "trial by combat."
- olefoo 18y agoThe agonistic system used in jurisdictions inheriting from english common law is trial by combat. It's supposed to work that way. The requirement of a disinterested judge, the structured dialogue of contending opinions; the whole notion of facing the accuser directly and of having a champion to represent your interests fall out of this. There are other judicial systems where a judge-advocate investigates and is supposed to arrive at the truth (mostly in nations that inherit from the Napoleonic Code); but anglo-saxon justice is explicitly a substitute for the duel.