4 ms·
That's why this is a Monty Hall problem. If you put the phase change material between the coffee and the insulation, it works. If you don't, it does not, becaus
by samatman 13y ago
That's why this is a Monty Hall problem. If you put the phase change material between the coffee and the insulation, it works. If you don't, it does not, because we are forgetting that the definition of heat is of a system, and heat exchange is on the interface. Coffee exchanges with a certain efficiency that is unaffected by the presence of a more efficient heat transfer material holding a reservoir of heat, unless that reservoir begins at a higher temperature.
You may need to go all the way back to definitions on this one, but it works out, and it predicts, correctly, that the effect is insignificant, per volume of coffee.
Yes, you can keep less coffee warmer longer by putting a volume inside it. That's not impressive. Can you keep the same amount of coffee warmer longer? You cannot.
- samatman 13y agoThe reason is that that Joulies, or anything else you put inside the system, displaces coffee out to a larger surface of interaction with the outside system. All other things being equal (basically, with a lid), it cancels out. Without a lid, convection is primary over any other factor, and the entire system will tend to reach equilibrium at about the same rate. Unless you a) add heat or b) reduce the rate of heat transfer at a surface, you cannot slow thermodynamic equlibrium.
- Retric 13y agoIf the heat transfer material is inside the coffee then the heat transfer is not just with the outside material but also with the phase change material. Also, even if the phase change material is the same temperature at the start, it becomes warmer at the point the phase change occurs. Now, increasing heat loss to the outside world is possible as the coffee surface area increases. However, that's vary much a question of cup design as a matalic vacuum thermos generally heats up the internal metallic part reasonobly evenly almost regardless of fluid level. PS: And if you don't believe me actually model the equations it works out after you realize drinking time only starts below an acceptable temperature.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]