4 ms·
"If however you don't have confidence in your hiring mechanisms, such that some duds make it past your hiring screens, then firing the lowest 5% may make a lot
by hga 13y ago
"If however you don't have confidence in your hiring mechanisms, such that some duds make it past your hiring screens, then firing the lowest 5% may make a lot of sense."
I'm not sure doing the above ever makes sense. We've heard of at least two severe problems with it at Microsoft, the worst 5% at gaming the system get zapped, and a tremendous amount of effort is devoted to not being in that lowest 5%, or managing who gets that every 6 months. E.g. managers retaining "deadwood" so they've got people to sacrifice in the future, and ultimately, as dalek_cannes puts it (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6267518 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6267518), "Stack ranking causes employees to compete with each other rather than the company's competitors. It's all downhill from there."
Anything you do in this direction, including not trying at all, will strongly affect your corporate culture and productivity; perhaps the best one can do is to strive to have "least worst" systems.
- tytso 13y agoYou can avoid this by making it a deep dark secret that you are firing the lowest 5% --- or that the reason why certain people are put on a PIP, subject to a "resource action", or "has found new opportunities outside of XXX" was due to the the fact that they fell into the lowest 5% bucket. I've seen this work at a past company at least reasonably well. A few people knew about the policy, but it wasn't something which was top of mind by all of the engineers, to the point where it started adversely affecting the company culture. (BTW, I'm not saying it was a good thing; and I'm glad I'm no longer working there. But if you don't worry about silly things like ethics, and only worry about maximizing shareholder value, it's a strategy that might work for a while.)
- xiphias 13y agoIn Google the employees on the same level in the whole company are mixed and randomly split to smaller groups, and stack ranked with people working in completely different teams, which means that teammates never compete with each other, but rather help each other to get promoted....this is totally different from what Microsoft does according to this post