3 ms·
Has anyone tried a social killfile? Almost all usenet clients had this wonderful feature called a killfile which would simply elide known-bad posters in a newsg
by javajosh 13y ago
Has anyone tried a social killfile? Almost all usenet clients had this wonderful feature called a killfile which would simply elide known-bad posters in a newsgroup. The regulars would have a largely (but not exactly) identical killfile, since the trolls were well known. A good group would often leave troll posts totally without responses - since no-one had even read it.
I always used to think it would be handy to have well-respected members of the group share their killfiles with others. Web-hosted forums could go one better and allow the easy sharing of killfiles between participants.
This kind of solution gives individuals freedom to see what data they want to see, but it also never takes away an individuals right to say whatever they want to say however they want to say it, however terrible or useless anyone thinks it is. There are no "moderators" per se, just people you respect well enough to copy their killfiles.
This relates to the OP's article because while it seems like a good idea to write down the rules of discourse, application of the rules will be arbitrary by nature, and so you have to let the community police itself in a scalable way.
- eksith 13y agoI'm an admin of a forum where we share ignore lists. I was very concerned about this at first because there's a very real chance that people will blindly ignore users based on others already ignoring them. However, for the most part, it seems users will still look at those shared lists as an "advisory" and still use their own discretion when choosing to ignore a user. There's also a feature where frequently ignored users will lose community standing (it works a bit like karma points except no numeric score is shown). Users with poor community standing will see an increase in the delay interval they're allowed to post. They will also not see new topics until a certain number of users with good community standing have already replied to those. The idea being that, perhaps, exposure to good quality posts will dissuade rubbish ones.
- lambada 13y agoSounds like an (partial)-inversion of a Web of Trust.