4 ms·
Insurance is not intended to pay out more money than you put in, it is intended to prevent gambler's ruin. Some extra money when you are in trouble is worth mo
by whatshisface 13y ago
Insurance is not intended to pay out more money than you put in, it is intended to prevent gambler's ruin.
Some extra money when you are in trouble is worth more than the money itself, it is also worth the trouble it gets you out of.
- nazgulnarsil 13y agoOr put another way: In your life you are optimizing over more than just money. Insurance is a way to reduce variance, and thus stress, and is therefore worth a nominal fee.
- Houshalter 13y agoAnother reason is what I believe economists call it "the law of decreasing marginal utility". Every extra dollar you have is (usually) worth less and less, since you pay for the things you want/need the most first, and money is only worth what you buy with it. Your expected utility is not your expected dollars. The average person will pay more into insurance than they get out of it. However it's worth it for the small chance that disaster could strike and you could lose everything. Better to sacrifice a small amount of utility to prevent losing a large amount from becoming homeless.
- gbog 13y agoMy point is not that insurance in itself is a scam. It would be rational to pay a small fee to a common account and get back much more when needed. It is how most communities work. My point is that the current insurance system and price is a scam, because it is much too expensive and covers to many silly cases. That's because it is very hard for human beings to evaluate the risk of something rare and its price. While this evaluation is exactly the job of insurance companies. It is the classic situation for a scam: the buyer can't know the real price. And we also have the symptoms: way too much money is spent on luxury in this industry, they have the most expensive tv ads, etc.
- Houshalter 13y agoThe buyer never knows the real price in any industry. How many people know how much it takes to build a factory, to pay the wages of all the workers, transportation costs, material costs, etc, etc. Competition is supposed to lower the price to it's actual amount. I don't see why this isn't true in the insurance industry.
- gbog 13y agoIn most other industries you can evaluate the price asked against the utility of the product out the service.
- actuary 13y agoThis is quite incorrect. I am a credentialed actuary responsible for the pricing of insurance risk. It is absolutely true that the consumer cannot price his or her own insurance policy (and I can). However, the end result of this is not some nefarious scenario where insurance companies are charging consumers ten times the fair price to insure their car or home. There is a functioning market for insurance, and consumers are going to tend to select the lowest-price option from amongst their choices in that market. This means that if you overcharge your customers, you will lose them to a competitor. Systematic mispricing of policies relative to the competition will lead to adverse selection, which is even worse - the insureds that you were making money on leave, and the insureds that you were losing money on stay. Because of these factors, the insurer's goal is to price your policy as accurately as possible. Profit margins in the personal lines are so thin that many insurers engage in what's called cash-flow underwriting. The only money they make on the policy is the investment income they earn on your prepaid premium. On top of all this, insurance (especially insurance marketed to consumers) is heavily regulated. Rate changes and new rating plans are scrutinized by each state's department of insurance. These regulators function like you wish the banking regulators did. They have enormous authority and their relationship with insurers is adversarial. I could go on at some length but I will cut it off here. Suffice it to say that insurance, particularly property/casualty insurance in the United States, is about as far from a scam as you can get.
- 13y ago