4 ms·
The biggest challenge with fishing is the ocean is largely a shared resource. The incentive to preserve and protect is much smaller, because you can just fish i
by sliverstorm 13y ago
The biggest challenge with fishing is the ocean is largely a shared resource. The incentive to preserve and protect is much smaller, because you can just fish in international waters or sneak over to somebody else's waters to fish, and conserving in your own waters may be fruitless because other people will come a'fishin!
Basically, one giant global tragedy of the commons.
- shmulkey18 13y agoPrecisely. No property rights, no desire to preserve property.
- benihana 13y agoIronically, recreational hunters solved this problem a long time ago. Give people a private plot and a quota and they will make sure populations stay healthy in that plot and surrounding areas. There are more whitetail deer in North America now after these kinds of hunting practices than there were when the first European settlers arrived. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White-tailed_deer#Human_interactions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White-tailed_deer#Human_interac...
- sliverstorm 13y agoThat's basically my point, though. The problem with the ocean is that this sort of solution has not been implemented and may in fact be very difficult to implement. The ocean is difficult to fence off, and the actors are basically states who have no superior authority that can truly enforce such things.
- apendleton 13y agoWhile in general you're right, deer aren't a great example. Deer populations in much of the US are actually higher than they historically would have been, largely because predator populations have been artificially and dramatically constrained. Most deer predators, but especially gray wolves, are also livestock predators, which has justified their population control.