4 ms·
The former point is correct as far as it goes. The latter is not. A cup of coffee loses heat around the perimeter, not the middle, and the rate of heat loss is
by samatman 13y ago
The former point is correct as far as it goes. The latter is not. A cup of coffee loses heat around the perimeter, not the middle, and the rate of heat loss is entirely determined by that perimeter. The only thing the Joulies can keep warmer than that equilibrium is themselves.
If they start warmer than the coffee, they may contribute to slowing the rate of heat loss. If they do not, they cannot.
I have come to think of this as the Monty Hall problem of thermodynamics. People with degrees similar to my own disagree with me all the time.
- samatman 13y agoTo forestall the most common objection: Yes, the joulies store more heat than water/coffee, by virtue of being denser. The phase change is irrelevant except as a trick; think of it as extra density you don't have to carry. You also don't get to drink it; it's more heat, but less coffee. Water/coffee stores more heat per gramme than either the phase change or the joulies, so unless you're short of volume, just insulate your coffee.
- Retric 13y agoIf they start warmer than the coffee, they may contribute to slowing the rate of heat loss. If they do not, they cannot. Except people don't drink 80C coffie so the absolute time it takes to reach 30C is less important than how long it spends in the drinkable range. Now I don't know what wax there using or how much, but Paraffin wax for example has about 1/2 the heat of fusion of water. So it would store enough energy to keep ~35 times as much water at a constant temperature rather than failing one degree c at which point the was would freeze and provide negligible benifit. On the other hand if the wax water ratio was 1:5 then the temperature would stabilize though 7 degrees worth of cooling when the coffie was 80C and then 7C of warming when the coffie was 37C which would be noticeable. Granted, 37C is a little to cold for coffie, other waxes have a higher melting point. PS: I still don't think this would be all that useful in practice. I am just pointing out it's not physically impossible.
- samatman 13y agoThat's why this is a Monty Hall problem. If you put the phase change material between the coffee and the insulation, it works. If you don't, it does not, because we are forgetting that the definition of heat is of a system, and heat exchange is on the interface. Coffee exchanges with a certain efficiency that is unaffected by the presence of a more efficient heat transfer material holding a reservoir of heat, unless that reservoir begins at a higher temperature. You may need to go all the way back to definitions on this one, but it works out, and it predicts, correctly, that the effect is insignificant, per volume of coffee. Yes, you can keep less coffee warmer longer by putting a volume inside it. That's not impressive. Can you keep the same amount of coffee warmer longer? You cannot.
- samatman 13y agoThe reason is that that Joulies, or anything else you put inside the system, displaces coffee out to a larger surface of interaction with the outside system. All other things being equal (basically, with a lid), it cancels out. Without a lid, convection is primary over any other factor, and the entire system will tend to reach equilibrium at about the same rate. Unless you a) add heat or b) reduce the rate of heat transfer at a surface, you cannot slow thermodynamic equlibrium.
- Retric 13y agoIf the heat transfer material is inside the coffee then the heat transfer is not just with the outside material but also with the phase change material. Also, even if the phase change material is the same temperature at the start, it becomes warmer at the point the phase change occurs. Now, increasing heat loss to the outside world is possible as the coffee surface area increases. However, that's vary much a question of cup design as a matalic vacuum thermos generally heats up the internal metallic part reasonobly evenly almost regardless of fluid level. PS: And if you don't believe me actually model the equations it works out after you realize drinking time only starts below an acceptable temperature.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]