7 ms·
X.Org Foundation Loses Its 501(c)(3) Status
- cperciva 13y agowe've Never filed returns since our first re-organization to the LLC in 2005. I was taken by surprize that the IRS hit us so rudely. Wait, am I reading this right? They've never filed tax returns for the past 8 years, but it's "rude" for the IRS to do something about it?
- vowelless 13y agoThat just sounds like incompetence; and from the article it seems that mismanaged accounting has been a recurring problem.
- MrZongle2 13y agoMr. Kreitman, X.Org accountant, is an idiot. If they were late to file for ONE year... maybe I'd be more sympathetic. But NEVER filing? Incompetence. Stupidity. There's no nicer way to put it, no other way to spin it.
- dnautics 13y agoyeah, if it is actually the case that they have had no revenue and no costs, then filing a 990 is dead simple. You write down a bunch of zeroes. It literally takes an hour. More importantly though, why did the board not clamp down on them?
- nolok 13y agoIsn't the fact that it takes an hour to say nothing happened a proof that the tax reporting system is way too convoluted ? Note that I'm not speaking in this particular case or trying to say it's not his fault (it is), but in general.
- kenko 13y agoNo? (If it really is just writing down a bunch of zeroes, though, it probably doesn't take a whole hour.)
- dnautics 13y agoYou do have to do a bit more than write down zeroes, you have to put your EIN on the top of every page, make sure your addresses are all correct, make sure you didn't miss any of the other little things, then take it to the post office, etc, etc, etc. It's seventeen pages of zeros and checks. If you want to see what a zeroed 990 looks like: https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0By7AdX1eMEY2LUp6SG1TZlpkTzA&usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0By7AdX1eMEY2LUp6SG1T... The careful eye will note on p. 13 where I screwed up on the e-version, and so the scanned (and sent) version has hand-written checkmarks. It's a good idea to dot your eyes and cross your ts on these forms. There's also a 199 there, which is the state equivalent of the federal form.
- shawnz 13y agoNot really. Consider that you're spending an hour per year to say that nothing happened for that whole year.
- freiheit 13y agohttp://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f990ez.pdf http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f990ez.pdf is probably what they needed to file. In the case of non-profits, the IRS is providing oversight that the non-profit is actually acting as a non-profit and doing good (very broadly defined) in the world. It's a check against people running a non-profit that doesn't do anything but make a few people rich.
- dnautics 13y agoX.org should probably be filing the full 990, especially if they expect to (someday) be pulling a lot of contributions. The 990EZ is more like for small local outfits that don't really expect to ever get big and expect to be mostly run on volunteer labor for the foreseeable future. They could get away with filing a 990EZ, but getting into the practice of doing the full 990 is not a bad idea.
- alex-g 13y agoWith receipts under $50k they could do a 990N, which is pretty much "what is your name?" and job done. (Their 2012 status report said they were spending $20-30k per year from a roughly $200k pot, with little attempt at raising more money for the time being.)
- Amadou 13y agoif it is actually the case that they have had no revenue and no costs, then filing a 990 is dead simple. If they had no revenue are they even required to file at all? I know that for personal income if you do not owe any additional tax than has already been collected then there is no requirement to file. Since they didn't get 501c3 status until 2012, the 990 doesn't seem appropriate except for this most recent year anyway.
- dnautics 13y ago>If they had no revenue are they even required to file at all? Yes. > Since they didn't get 501c3 status until 2012, the 990 doesn't seem appropriate except for this most recent year anyway. All nonprofits with an EIN need to file 990s even if you don't have 501(c)(3) status. Corporations are not individuals so there are different rules. The rules for registered nonprofits are stricter than for-profits - AND screwing them up can jeopardize attempts to get 501(c)(3) down the line, although typicially the IRS will be reasonable, if you make a handful of trivial mistakes here and there they won't kill you.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- eCa 13y agoAlso: I've had little issues with my own returns and have always found them to be reasonable and friendly. I'm not a US citizen, but I would expect the IRS to behave differently when dealing with organizations as opposed to citizens?
- dudurocha 13y agoThat's the purpose of a corporation. That's why we have something called a judicial person. To separate this kind of thing.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mscarborough 13y ago> we've Never filed returns since our first re-organization to the LLC in 2005. I'm sure plenty of HNers can attest, you aren't exempt from taxes because you're an LLC. Plenty of us file our own LLC taxes, yet a 'professional' accountant in charge of a full organization thought it would be an OK business thing to ignore altogether? Hopefully they find better representation, this is egregious.
- rgbrenner 13y agoThe article never calls him a "professional accountant". He's the accountant of X.org, but in fairness, he's really a system engineer. He's never been an accountant anywhere: http://www.linkedin.com/pub/stuart-kreitman/5/185/942 http://www.linkedin.com/pub/stuart-kreitman/5/185/942 So he's really just an engineer that they gave the accounting work to. That probably explains quite a bit.
- Zelphyr 13y agoNot really. Most engineers I know are at least smart enough to know that if you don't pay your taxes for eight years you're going to have a problem with the IRS.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoYup, experience taught me that in 1/8th of that amount if time.
- nknighthb 13y agoActually he's Treasurer, which means he has responsibility for an organization's money, but does not necessarily perform the functions of an accountant. When giving the role to someone without any particular expertise, you would expect a professional accountant to be retained to advise and assist in any nontrivial case. But since nobody thought to file taxes (or make sure they got filed), I'm assuming they didn't think to do that either. This degree of incompetence is troubling, especially given the massive array of resources X.Org could have called on for help in ensuring the foundation was being run correctly.
- mathattack 13y agoHow did they get the status to begin with if they never filed taxes?
- mentat 13y agoThe law changed relatively recently. It used to be that 501c3s didn't have to file if they didn't have income.
- sliverstorm 13y agoWhere, "relatively recently" means 5 years ago.
- mentat 13y agoFor organizations like that one I was associated with who had been tax exempt for 40+ years, yes, relatively recently.
- sliverstorm 13y agoI don't mean to say 5 years is ancient history, just to give some context, as it certainly wasn't implemented last year. 5 years is not an unreasonable timeframe in which to learn about changes!
- brazzy 13y agoDo you actively and regularly check for changes in all laws that might apply to you?
- sliverstorm 13y agoCertainly not every category of law, but I do pay close attention to tax law, and I'm not even an accountant.
- nknighthb 13y ago
- mentat 13y agoIt changed in 2008 for 501c3s: http://www.irs.gov/Charities-&-Non-Profits/Exempt-Organizations---Required-Filings http://www.irs.gov/Charities-&-Non-Profits/Exempt-Organizati... Having been in another non-profit that also failed to notice this, if you ask the IRS very nicely, they'll usually let you come back into compliance quickly.
- short_circut 13y agoThis is why laws need change logs for when they are modified. I knows bills have something of the sort, but they are hard to follow. Anyone who finds a specific set of laws relevant can subscribe to them and get an email when the law is changed.
- lambada 13y agoBut they only became a 501(c)(3) in 2012. Before that 2005-2012 they were an LLC, and so thus most definitely weren't exempt.
- n3rdy 13y agoWell they are demanding money that doesn't belong to them, and they threaten you with physical violence or death if you refuse to comply. I don't even think "rude" is a proper description for that type of behavior. I consider it extortion.
- eli 13y agoKinda sounds like they'd be much better off under the umbrella of another organization anyway.
- jamesaguilar 13y ago> "The status of the 501c3 is lost because we (me) failed to file the 3 past years' tax returns on time. Note that we've Never filed returns since our first re-organization to the LLC in 2005. I was taken by surprize that the IRS hit us so rudely. I've had little issues with my own returns and have always found them to be reasonable and friendly." I'm not an accountant, so I can't make a definitive statement, but this sounds like really poor accounting to me. Maybe that's too specific. It sounds like really poor management of responsibility and time in general. If you're not going to do the work, you should at least tell the person you are responsible to so they can replace you. If I were his manager and I heard about this, I'd be double checking his work for quite some time to make sure he wasn't under-performing his role at his actual job too.
- nicholassmith 13y agoWait, what? There's an accountant and they've never bothered filing and now he's distressed because normally the IRS is super helpful? Fire that accountant, get someone who's going to take it seriously.
- throwaway92785 13y agoYou can't fire a volunteer.
- cdcarter 13y agoAs someone who's been a volunteer coordinator for an organization using ~550 volunteers a year, yes, you can fire a volunteer.
- nsmartt 13y agoYes, of course you can. Why couldn't you?
- dragonwriter 13y ago> You can't fire a volunteer. Its actually easier to file a volunteer, since, compared to a paid employee, they are less likely to have any claim against you if you do and they aren't happy with it. Of course, it can be hard to get a better replacement for the same money for an incompetent volunteer in a skilled field, but that's an issue of difficulty replacing the volunteer, not difficulting firing them.
- nine_k 13y ago> X.Org has lost funds in the past due to banking issues, PayPal issues, and an assortment of other actions due to either delayed action or inaction on the behalf of the accountant and the board. That's why we need Wayland and Mir, right?
- skadamat 13y agoWow what a bunch of morons
- webreac 13y agoAm I the only one to read that an Oracle employee has caused damages to an open source organisation ?
- srl 13y agoPretty sure Hanlon's razor is in full force here. Oracle's done enough shitty stuff - we don't need to go out of our way to pin nonsense like this on them. (Besides, AFAIK, X.org is in no way a competitor to any part of oracle, so it's not like they care.)
- altero 13y agoLOL
- jostmey 13y agoHere is an example where the IRS has gone after a legitimate non-profit organization. And yet how many organizations maintain non-profit status as a way to avoid higher taxes?
- percentcer 13y agoPresumably more than the number that skip tax filing entirely as a way to avoid higher taxes.
- freiheit 13y agoNo, it's not. When you're a non-profit, you file paperwork with the IRS (a form 990 or 990-EZ) that details your income, expenses, officers of the corporation, highest paid employees/contractors (especially ones receiving over $100k), programs (and their accomplishments), etc. You don't actually pay any taxes, but you do "file taxes with the IRS". The data in that form 990 is used to back up the fact that you are legitimately a non-profit corporation serving the public interest. If a non-profit isn't filing their form 990 every year, they don't look legitimate at all. They probably aren't legitimate if they're not filing a form 990. The article mentions that they hadn't done any major fundraising drivers or solicitations for donations from major corporations. If they weren't filing the form 990 for years, that's no surprise, since the form 990 is public information that any major donor would know to look at (or to look at a summary or analysis of the information via guidestar or something like that). Look at the summary of this information and ask yourself if you'd donate $1 after you read it: http://www.guidestar.org/organizations/26-4691413/xorg-foundation.aspx http://www.guidestar.org/organizations/26-4691413/xorg-found...
- Zelphyr 13y agoWait. So they didn't even actually owe any money? All they had to do is send the IRS a form (and potentially an EZ one at that) once a year? I wouldn't consider myself litigious but it sounds to me like there is a legal case against the X.org board and this "accountant".
- j_m_b 13y agoI like that their minutes are irc logs http://www.x.org/wiki/BoardOfDirectors/IrcLogs/ http://www.x.org/wiki/BoardOfDirectors/IrcLogs/
- darcrossito 13y agoSomeone forgot to google basic stuff. http://www.nonprofitrisk.org/library/articles/How_to_Lose_Your_Tax_Exempt_Status.shtml http://www.nonprofitrisk.org/library/articles/How_to_Lose_Yo...
- erbo 13y agoI want to see something like "The people responsible for this utter incompetence have been sacked. And the people responsible for sacking those people responsible for this utter incompetence have also been sacked."
- afreak 13y agoThere are two organisations that I fear: - Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) - Department of Fisheries and Oceans (long story) I do not fear CSIS, the RCMP, or the CSE oddly. The CRA (like the IRS) will make your life a living hell if you do not file properly. I was once a member of a not-for-profit organisation that was shutdown by the CRA due to the incompetence of its treasurer. The treasurer refused to file on a yearly basis under the guise that it wasn't necessary. It was difficult to remove the person as it was a three-person body that ran the NFP company with a directors board underneath to handle all other affairs--I had several years in the directors board. Looking back it was a dumb structure but it made sense at the time at least. Eventually the CRA got wind of our not-filing due to our status as a corporation under the Business Corporations Act in British Columbia, and thus seized all assets and shut it down. It recently rebirthed as a non-profit organisation (with people who do know what the hell they're doing), but it left a good friend of mine almost in a compromised financial state, another person unable to get a business of their own due to disqualification from tax credits, and another person (the treasurer themselves) ended up going AWOL. Don't fuck with the government body that wants your tax dollars even if you don't have to do anything more than fill out a one-page form.
- cperciva 13y agoThe CRA (like the IRS) will make your life a living hell if you do not file properly If you don't file at all, sure. If you make the occasional mistake? Not really a problem -- the CRA just phones up and asks you to clarify the situation. I've had my tax returns fixed this way several times, without any penalties or even paperwork required.
- afreak 13y agoInnocent mistake? Probably going to be fine. Not filing because you're clueless? Different story.
- raldi 13y ago> Department of Fisheries and Oceans (long story) Oh no, don't you dare. You cannot just say something like that and then just leave the entire Internet hanging.
- gyepi 13y agoOn the surface, this seems like a tale of incompetence but the board seems to have taken it in stride, is considering joining a larger organization and wondered why they had not made the move sooner. In context, this is much less of a story than it appears. http://www.x.org/wiki/BoardOfDirectors/IrcLogs/2013/08-22/ http://www.x.org/wiki/BoardOfDirectors/IrcLogs/2013/08-22/
- cdcarter 13y ago"Per the IRC meeting minutes, the board is now thinking about having the X.Org Foundation join an umbrella organization like the SPI, the Apache Foundation, or other free-software-focused organizations for riding some benefits like a non-profit status while having to deal less in paperwork and other managerial matters." I do hope that any organization that considers offering fiscal sponsorship or controlling X.Org entirely requires a full comprehensive audit before moving forward. "Deal[ing] less in paperwork" is something you get to do when your finances are in good condition, not when they're a wreck.
- nknighthb 13y agoI think it more likely the X.Org Foundation would just dissolve. The licensing ensures that moving the project is a simple matter of the individual developers choosing to operate under a different banner. No link needs to be established between the foundation and SPI/Apache/whatever. The only question is where the X trademarks might be. If they're still with the Open Group, no problem. If they got transferred, it's a little more complicated.