2 ms·
> You (and I mean you specifically) can obviously look at a new use and say "this is a new meaning" or "no, this is an error", but that's a subjective judgement
by JoshTriplett 13y ago
> You (and I mean you specifically) can obviously look at a new use and say "this is a new meaning" or "no, this is an error", but that's a subjective judgement and others would think otherwise.
Hence me talking about "widespread". If the consensus of the vast majority of people says that a usage is incorrect, then a helpful dictionary should properly document that that usage will be perceived as incorrect. Writing "there" when you mean "their" or "they're" usually produces a sentence that can be understood in context (our language parsers are remarkably resilient), but will make the writer look like they either don't know or don't care, and will create a strong negative impression in those who read it.
Dictionaries should document widespread usages, even incorrect ones. Dictionaries often attach information to meanings like "archaic" or "frequently misused as" or "frequently confused with".
For example, a dictionary can and should add a note to "their" saying "frequently confused with they're and there". There's absolutely nothing wrong with that. But as long as the vast majority of people consider sentences like "there sentence structure needed some work" incorrect, a dictionary should not claim that "there" is a possessive pronoun without attaching the caveat that anyone reading it will consider it incorrect.
(This response applies to several replies.)