3 ms·
I watched Who Wants to be a Millionaire quite frequently, and it's interesting how the crowd fails when it fails to provide the right answer. The problem is alw
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
I watched Who Wants to be a Millionaire quite frequently, and it's interesting how the crowd fails when it fails to provide the right answer. The problem is always the same. People who don't really know do not vote randomly and they do not abstain. They vote for the cliche and therefore don't cancel each other out.
90% accuracy from hundereds of people is actually pretty bad. A few people in the crowd undoubtedly know the right answer but they have no way of telling the others that they do. The "ask a friend" life line has the advantage that the friend will tell them how certain he or she is. So the contestant can at least disregard that opinion.
So my conclusion is that wisdom of the crowds doesn't even work very well in those areas where it is supposed to work well. We rarely work in an environment that is similar to the cookie jar example. Most of the time we are surrounded by cliches and ideologies. That's why I'm usually very reluctant to believe a source that cannot tell me how it knows what it claims to know.