3 ms·
I've always thought the misuse of "beg the question", if not actively fought and corrected, would be precedent for all manner of linguistic perversions. Just th
by danso 13y ago
I've always thought the misuse of "beg the question", if not actively fought and corrected, would be precedent for all manner of linguistic perversions. Just this week I saw it misused in the New York Times by a quoted scientist. This case of "literally" is just us reaping what we sew for not towing the line.
http://begthequestion.info/ http://begthequestion.info/
- venus 13y ago> This case of "literally" is just us reaping what we sew for not towing the line. Literally.
- lutusp 13y ago> This case of "literally" is just us reaping what we sew for not towing the line. Nice examples. I also regularly see "reigning in" when "reining in" is what's meant. Reigning is what a monarch does to a kingdom, reining is what a cowboy does to a horse.
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoThe latter two are examples of Mondegreens (or eggcorns): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondegreen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondegreen Actually, reading the article, it seems to make the distinction that those would be malapropisms instead: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malapropism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malapropism
- James_Duval 13y agoThe thing is, "beg the question" as it is used in everyday language is much more transparent and easier to understand than its 'proper' usage. If you want to describe that specific fallacy in some way, there's a lovely phrase for that which already exists, describes the fallacy better, and uses fewer words - "petitio principii". "Beg the question" used in this sense strikes me as redundant, inaccurate as a translation and a description, clunky, and pointlessly confusing. I hope its misuse is not actively fought, and that people who wish to describe the fallacy find a better way of doing so.
- lunchbox 13y agoAnother name for "begging the question" is simply "circular reasoning"
- dragonwriter 13y ago> The thing is, "beg the question" as it is used in everyday language is much more transparent and easier to understand than its 'proper' usage. Even better, it is impossible to confuse with the "proper" usage (because it is distinct syntactically) and makes the "proper" usage more transparent and easier to understand. The everyday form is transitive, its always "<foo> raises the question <bar>" and means "Accepting <foo> creates the need for a resolution of the issue <bar>". The "proper" form is intransitive, its always simply "<foo> raises the question", meaning "<foo> invokes the petitio principii fallacy". This can be rephrased, however, as "<foo> creates the need for a resolution of the issue <bar>" where <bar> is the proposition argument <foo> was offered to justify, as it is stating that the argument depends on the conclusion it was offered to support.