5 ms·
Penny Auctions: They're Gambling
- sireat 17y agoThese penny auctions are just a variation of the infamous dollar auction: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dollar_auction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dollar_auction I do hope that people who get taken realize what a horrible deal it is after the first try. Sadly most will keep trying again and again. As a device of gambling/entertainment these "auctions" would be fine if the returns would be somewhat regulated, that is house take would never be above 200% (even 120% would probably be fine).
- edmccaffrey 17y agoThe metrics that he invented to determine if it is a game of chance are contrived and outright dumb. It's not a game of chance because anyone can win if they are willing to spend more than the other bidders. Even though people can try to use bidding strategies, it is not a game of chance. Keep this terrible blog far, far away, please.
- jerf 17y agoNot so much. I wrote about this in more depth here: http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2888 http://www.jerf.org/iri/post/2888 and I won't entirely repeat myself, except I would point out that they sometimes run "special" auctions where the "auction" price is free, and all you pay is the bid price. In that case there is 0 ability to "win"; it's straight-up gambling. Even in the case where you are willing to put a lot of money into a "full price" auction, the ability that someone else has to put one dollar + auction price in and defeat your 2 * auction price dollars in bidding + auction price makes it unlikely you will win without "investing" radically more than the value of the product. (Especially since they are trying to create a bidding war between 2 or more people each of which are unaware of the "sunk cost fallacy", or at least not able to act on it.) I'm not sure what metric you would prefer, but if you feel it's dumb and not gambling, I would invite you to try it. Me? I'll be over here, not trying it. I can work the math. But feel free to let us know how it goes. If you'd like an easier metric, just go to the site and find a currently active item. Simulate yourself hitting the "bid" button, and keep track of how often you do it, and whether you win the item. Until you sit there and watch the counter in real time (as I did on a couple of items), you can't feel how this site works. (And since Swoopo may end up here, I'll repeat what I said on my blog: I am completely uninterested in hearing from you, Swoopo.)
- mcargian 17y agoAlthough it may be evil and expensive, it is absolutely not gambling. The last person to bid, wins. There is no chance, no draw, no random event. The last person gets it.
- branden 17y agoMore accurately, you win if yours is the last bid to reach the server. You have less control over that than you think. Unless you pay for their premium service, of course.
- diego 17y agoExcept getting the item is not winning. It's only winning if you pay less than retail price.
- sachinag 17y agoNo, and this is where most people make the mistake. The winner of any auction is the last and highest bidder. Whether or not it is rational to bid more than retail is irrelevant to determining the winner of an auction. People conflate "I would never do that" with "no one would ever do that".
- diego 17y agoYou didn't understand my point. Winning is not getting the item. I define winning as paying less than it would cost at Amazon or wherever you would buy it. If you pay $20 in bids plus $50 for an item that costs $65 at Amazon, you lost $5 (even if your time is free). Yes, you "won" the auction but the real winner in economic terms is the house. [edit: what is the point of participating in an auction for commodity goods other than to pay less than retail? I assume that people who take part in this site do it in the hope of coming out ahead, not to win an auction at any cost even if it means paying more than the item is worth. I don't see how users of this site can confuse "winning an auction" with winning in economic terms]
- jellicle 17y agoIn the past few years, we've seen mortgage-backed securities and financial derivatives and hedge funds become household words. Each of these were ways to game the existing regulatory system. Take dollars, contort them in a way that appears new, and loudly declare you aren't subject to any existing regulations. The regulators won't catch up for several years, and by then you've taken whole generations of investors to the cleaners. Swoopo isn't an auction, it's a raffle. When your school sells 500 $1 raffle tickets for a $100 prize, the raffle buyers understand that the school is going to profit $400 and the kids are going to get to go to band camp, and the government which regulates games of chance has given it a pass (typically, raffles may have to apply for a permit from a government agency, and only bonafide religious, charitable, or education groups are allowed to do it without the heavy regulations applied to casinos and the like). Swoopo just decided to call themselves a legal auction rather than an illegal raffle, and they're waiting until the regulators catch up with them. Then they'll slightly alter how the scam works, loudly declare this new system is perfectly legal and isn't subject to any existing regulation, and start all over again. This type of internet-scamming is going to be increasingly common, and programmers really need an ethical duty not to participate. It's like a 3-card monte, or free throw shooting game where the basket is oblong rather than round, but, hey, over the internet.... call it Carnival Scams 2.0. The populace has NO IMMUNITY against this sort of thing so it's going to go through them like swine flu.
- randallsquared 17y agoThis type of internet-scamming is going to be increasingly common, and programmers really need an ethical duty not to participate. It's not clear to me that it's unethical to build a tool that someone could use to harm themselves. Further, you've just described how this will go on anyway ("censorship as damage" and all that).
- ispivey 17y agoThe really shady thing is how Swoopo shows the same auctions to people bidding with different currencies. Look at the front pages of these two sites: http://www.swoopo.com/ http://www.swoopo.com/ and http://www.swoopo.co.uk/ http://www.swoopo.co.uk/ You probably won't see the same items I do, but I'm sure you'll note two ridiculous (dishonest?) things: 1) You'll see the same item listed for the same number of US Dollars as Pounds Sterling (e.g. I see an iPhone for $86.50 and £86.50, with the same "countdown" running). This is not outright deceptive for penny auctions because, after all, the current "bid" is just a score, not an actual value that anyone ever pays. 2) You'll see that people in the US and UK are bidding against each other on the same auction, but people in the US and UK think they're bidding on different items. For example, I see on the US site a Sony VAIO VGN-AW220J/B 18.4-Inch Laptop for $10.27 with 2:45 remaining, and on the UK site a Acer Aspire 8930G 18.4" Notebook for £10.27 with 2:45 remaining. If you click through to both auctions, you'll see the same people and bids on both - they're clearly the same auction. Presumably when someone finally bids, Swoopo buys whatever item they think they won and ships it to them.
- jraines 17y agoI usually like to take the devil's advocate position in this argument, because I don't think you have to be as smart as HN thinks[1] to understand what you're getting into when you enter these auctions -- but in this case, yeah that's freaking evil. [1] In comment below: "populace has NO IMMUNITY . . .it will run through them like swine flu". Come on. Has the populace moved to Nevada and dashed themselves upon the rocks of Vegas? Are we a nation of lottery addicts and OTB junkies? I bet if this were about drugs and/or prostitution, few here would be saying "the populace has NO IMMUNITY to instantly available pleasure and distraction! It will run through them like swine flu!"
- Retric 17y agoI like to gamble and understand that the math is not on your side, but when you "win" 40+% of the time the mind plays tricks and you can quickly develop a MMO style addiction. However, with all the negative feedback I can dump 5$ on 180million to 1 odds and still have fun without getting that sort of feedback. PS: As long as you recognize gamboling is about having a sadistic sort of fun and spend a tiny % of your income, you can get a lot of entertainment for your dollar.
- ispivey 17y agoTheoretically, these auctions could (and should) continue indefinitely, because every time a new bid is placed the remaining auction time is extended. Because of this indefinite extension, and because the way most people play this auction game is by spending up to a certain percentage of the value of the item (<= 100%), it's definitely a gambling game. You're gambling that some other new bidder will not happen upon the auction before your bidding allowance runs out. If they do, you're screwed. If they don't, you can win. That's the most important reason Swoopo funnels as many bidders as possible to as few auctions as possible - it drags out the auctions, allowing them to collect as many bids (dollars) as possible for the fewest prizes delivered.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]