6 ms·
If the US is nowhere near being an authoritarian police state, at what point will US become a authoritarian police state? When they have kill lists without any
by belorn 13y ago
If the US is nowhere near being an authoritarian police state, at what point will US become a authoritarian police state?
When they have kill lists without any trial, jury or judge?
When they keep prisoners in jail indefinitely without a trial?
When they torture prisoners?
When state officials lie to the public?
When state officials lie to public representatives?
When the secret police interfere with lawyers communications and interferes with legal cases?
When the secret police silence individuals that want to inform about abuse?
When the secret police use surveillance for blackmailing?
When the state use strip searches and surveillance indiscriminately against the population, including children?
When the state implement state censorship?
When they use force against peaceful demonstrators?
When they utilize military resources against peaceful demonstrators?
When they seize bank assets without any trial, any intention of a trial, or even without ever formally serving the individual with criminal papers?
Please state what criteria we should use, so we can have a final definition of what an authoritarian police state is.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoAll of those criteria, plus I think an extra criterion that they have to happen to so many people that it reaches some kind of tipping point where there's a mass consensus that things are authoritarian. Just to be clear, I'm not excusing the abuses you've listed.
- nohuck13 13y agoThe thing about rule law is that it's not about critical mass. It's the edge cases that are important. It's easy to have justice the majority of the time. If the state can arbitrarily subvert the rules just because they think it's really really important, that's not rule of law. I know you're not arguing that it is, you're more talking about public opinion. I think you're probably right. But I wish that weren't the reality.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoWell, perhaps we can see things on a line from perfect rule of law to perfect authoritarianism, with the understanding that no state is ever completely at one end or the other. I think we're still less than half way to authoritarianism.
- smokeyj 13y agoAll governments demand obedience. That's why they have a monopoly on violence. Any entity which wields a monopoly on violence for the purpose of controlling the actions of others is authoritarian in nature. I can't imagine what you mean by "perfect rule of law", but I do know it isn't the antithesis of authoritarianism. The opposite of strict obedience to authority is no obedience to authority -- meaning no hierarchy -- or anarchy. My point is, we're judging how authoritarian a dictator is based on how benevolent they are. While a dictator is capable of ruling.. "equitably", the fact is you still have a dictator who could change his mind tomorrow. So it's not that we're mad about having a dictator, we're just mad this dictator is being a bigger ass hole than yesterday.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoThat's a good point about anarchy. Although anarchy and authoritarianism are opposites, they behave in very similar ways: the people with power call the shots as they please. In the middle, you could say we have perfect rule of law. This means that no officials act as if they are above the law, and that every moral injustice is handled by some law or another. Clearly we'll never have that. So the first continuum I proposed is actually one half of the continuum between anarchy and authoritarianism.
- JabavuAdams 13y agoWell, the obvious answer is that the rule of law is a fiction. As you point out, even if it's true for most of us, most of the time, it's the edge cases (abuses) that matter most.
- jcc80 13y agoExactly. Right now the "in your face" abuse is happening to a relatively small portion of people (privacy of millions being violated but they don't all feel it yet). Easy for everyone else to sit back in comfort and think it won't happen to them or the others somehow deserved it. When it happens to more people then an outrageous edge case can serve as the tipping point.
- ejk314 13y agoFirst they came for the brown people, but I did not speak out because I was not a brown person...
- dsuth 13y agoThe problem is, by the time it affects enough of the general public, it's already to late. It's the classic "First they came for..." problem.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoDo you seriously think that classic examples of XX century authoritarian states had mass consensus that they are authoritarian? That would be a post-modern authoritarian state.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI suppose it has to be mass consensus among the persecuted class and the friends of the persecuted class.
- madaxe 13y agoBut all of those criteria are already true in both the US and the UK. I think that was his point.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI don't believe there's a mass consensus that it's an authoritarian regime. I'm not even sure there's a mass consensus that it's heading in that direction, regardless of what I personally believe.
- madaxe 13y agoNo, and I don't think that a mass consensus is in any way relevant to determining whether something is an authoritarian regime or not. There was never a mass consensus in the USSR that it was authoritarian, because it was not permitted. When I say not permitted, I do not mean that they had people with guns going "THINK THIS!", but that social pressure and group-think were utilised to ensure that nobody broke ranks - just like media control in the US and UK ensures. It's very easy to rule people by pitting them against one another, and putting them in a state of fear, envy or suspicion of their fellow cit.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoSo, okay, how do you determine it then? If those things listed each happened once, it wouldn't be authoritarian. (Would it?) What about twice? Three times? There has to be some threshold. I couldn't think of a better threshold than some kind of consensus, because it's essentially a value judgment. But, it's a good point about group-think. Maybe there has to be a consensus among people outside of the marginalized group? Maybe the fact that people are even openly questioning whether we have an authoritarian regime in the US means that we don't? Perhaps things are authoritarian when a wide range of people expect abuse from the people in power, whether or not they recognize it as such. Or, maybe it's more sinister than that, and we only truly recognize authoritarianism in retrospect.
- 13y ago
- krelian 13y agoWhen we can longer have this discussion, either because access to the means that make it possible has been barred from us or because the risk is too great.
- specialist 13y agoWhen we can longer have this discussion In the USA, it'll be when discussion becomes moot. The ruling elite need not prohibit free speech when no one is listening.
- angersock 13y agoOn the contrary, allowing us all to fill their dossiers with our words and giving the thugs the rope with which to bind us when the time comes makes more sense, and also fits better with an automated solution.
- JabavuAdams 13y agoAll of these are abuses of power, and should be opposed. That said, I'm confident that there is no nation state on Earth that hasn't done these things. Please correct me if you can think of examples. The difference now is that they are affecting mainstream, middle-class, "normal" Americans. While it's good that people are angry about these abuses, it also seems incredibly naive. This is what states do. This is what they've always done. This is not particularly more authoritarian than they've been in the past. There was no glorious past. There were no good old days.
- a_bonobo 13y ago>That said, I'm confident that there is no nation state on Earth that hasn't done these things. Please, tell me one "first-world" country that has kill lists??
- madaxe 13y agoThe USA?
- rahoulb 13y agohttp://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/14/obama-secret-kill-list-disposition-matrix http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/14/obama-secret-ki...
- brymaster 13y agoWow, you need to pay attention more.
- a_bonobo 13y agoI can't edit my (old) post, I meant non-US-countries as the OP was implying. Does the current German Republic carry kill-lists? Nope.
- aspensmonster 13y ago>If the US is nowhere near being an authoritarian police state, at what point will US become a authoritarian police state? When it's too late to do anything about it.
- wfunction 13y agoThis response is gold.
- comex 13y agoDunno. When it becomes illegal to oppose the current government? When there is any political ideology it is illegal to espouse that does not involve directly inciting people to commit crimes? When it becomes illegal to stage mass protests about anything? When the media is directly owned by the state, as it is in many places? When journalists and activists are jailed, as they are in many places? When the media feels in any way uncomfortable roundly criticizing the government? When the media feels too uncomfortable to openly publish government secrets which were previously leaked? When most people think the government is authoritarian and needs to be reined in? When enough people think the government is authoritarian that, under a democratic system, they would be a powerful voting bloc? When at least enough people think the government is authoritarian for the idea to be given serious consideration in mainstream debates? (Debate about specific programs that need to be curtailed, without a general sense that the government is comparable to a police state, do not count.) When we don't see things happening like a rightwing antigovernment political movement becoming very popular and taking over a significant portion of the legislature; a leftwing anticapitalist political movement staging provocative long-term demonstrations around the country with, at the end of the day, mostly pretty reasonable interactions with various municipal police departments, and managing at least to significantly influence the debate; a judge placing harsh limits on a practice by a city's police department that was found to be unconstitutional? Wikipedia cites the following elements of authoritarianism: (1) "limited, not responsible, political pluralism"; that is, constraints on political institutions and groups (such as legislatures, political parties, and interest groups), (2) a basis for legitimacy based on emotion, especially the identification of the regime as a necessary evil to combat "easily recognizable societal problems" such as underdevelopment or insurgency; (3) neither "intensive nor extensive political mobilization" and constraints on the mass public (such as repressive tactics against opponents and a prohibition of antiregime activity) and (4) "formally ill-defined" executive power, often shifting or vague. Let's see: (1) Not applicable. (2) Nationalism and emotional support for the government in general is alive and perhaps too well, but politicians almost never attempt to use such emotional arguments to support keeping themselves in power rather than electing the other party. (3) Political mobilization is fine. No repression. Prosecuting leakers, whether you oppose it or not, does not count. (4) There are issues regarding Congressional oversight of certain executive programs, but there are certainly limits on the President's power. In fact, on the kinds of issues (economic, social) that the current President spends most of his time talking about, he seems to get his way remarkably rarely. It is possible to criticize moves that are abuses of power or resemble those of an authoritarian police state in some aspects without literally, and incorrectly, calling the US an authoritarian police state.
- girvo 13y agoIt's like porn. You know it when you see it.
- flumbaps 13y agoThe US will become an authoritarian police state when it starts silencing all opposition to the state as a matter of course. That isn't the case yet. However, the processes, institutions and technology available to the US government already seem quite capable of facilitating authoritarian control. Personally, I suspect that it's just a matter of time. All the things you talk about have happened, but they happen rarely. With the right leadership in power, they could easily start to become commonplace. The thing is, anyone who says something that doesn't conform to state ideology can be said to be aiding terrorists, by spreading an "extremist" message and implicitly encouraging others towards terrorism. The general public seem quite happy with whatever treatment "terrorists" get, so I can't see there being much standing in the way.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoThat's quite a laundry list. Links with each would give it more effect, though.
- belorn 13y agoI considered it, but it would mostly distract from the otherwise very interesting discussion surrounding the definition of an an authoritarian police state. For example, when ever someone say the word torture, there is always someone who would argue that simulated death and forcing up hoses into peoples noses to force-feed them is somehow not torture. By focusing on the general case rather than specific cases, the discussion in this thread has been of so much higher quality. That said, if any of the statement sound surprising, I am more than happy to re-locate the source which inspired that sentence.