5 ms·
...capitalism vs socialism alone, it's much more nuanced than that. Profiteering. Seems pretty simple to me. I'm exhausted by the -ism debates and mythical fr
by specialist 13y ago
...capitalism vs socialism alone, it's much more nuanced than that.
Profiteering. Seems pretty simple to me.
I'm exhausted by the -ism debates and mythical free markets. To me, it's about the incentives. So I support a single payer using the capitation model, reward wellness vs treating disease.
With ACA (Obamacare), I hope that we're on our way towards single payer in the USA. Meanwhile, I'm impressed with improvements gained so far with the modest initial reforms (eg health exchanges).
Who would have thought that a well regulated market with price transparency would lead to price competition? /sarcasm
- refurb 13y agoProfiteering is too simplistic of explanation. If you read up on the various regulations and how they create incentives for hospitals to do this, it makes more sense. And you have to be careful with the regulations you institute. A LOT of the current problems with the US healthcare system are due to gov't regulations. If you want to see an example, just google "average selling price ASP" and see the utter mess that regulation created for Medicare. Doctors and pharmacists milk the hell out of that gov't regulation. Same with 340b.
- specialist 13y agoSo fewer regulations will lower healthcare costs in the USA?
- ahallock 13y agoThe free markets are mythical because they're not allowed to happen. Single payer is a horrible idea. Why would you trust a centralized agency (which can be bribed and corrupted so easily) with such an essential service? The government purchasing healthcare from outside organizations is bound to be overrun with special interests and obscene contracts (like we see with the military). I want to be able to vote with my wallet; I don't want a single entity, especially one that can levy taxes and borrow massive amounts of money from the Fed, to have a monopoly. The State will then just choose winners and losers, make certain activities illegal so we can't test alternatives, etc. I just don't see how that can end well.
- specialist 13y agoPlease provide an example of a free market. Why do the existing single payer systems outperform the USA's private health plan system, measured in both cost per capita and life expectancy?
- sseveran 13y agoBecause of measurements (like including high speed highway deaths) that make other systems look relatively better.
- cromwellian 13y agosingle-payer != single provider. Single Payer systems are insurance, they don't provide service, they doll out cash. The only function of an insurance company is to pool funds and distribute them. In theory, overhead should be very low and there's not much to innovate on except to figure out the best ways to deny coverage or detect fraud.