3 ms·
> His affiliation means his facts and actual investigation of the full story are suspect. That is one of the most blatant statements of a textbook fallacy I've
by baddox 13y ago
> His affiliation means his facts and actual investigation of the full story are suspect.
That is one of the most blatant statements of a textbook fallacy I've seen in a while. The affiliations and motivations of the arguer do not affect the trueness of facts or the validity of arguments.
- alanh 13y agoI knew I’d see this comment before I opened the HN discussion. Yes, it is fallacious to reject arguments to do the source. No, it is not unreasonable to use known facts about a speaker to weight the trust placed into their statements!