5 ms·
You left out Tesla suing television show Top Gear for libel. (Which they lost despite the UK's infamously plaintiff-friendly libel laws.)
by eli 13y ago
You left out Tesla suing television show Top Gear for libel. (Which they lost despite the UK's infamously plaintiff-friendly libel laws.)
- TrevorJ 13y agoI think that may have been less about winning the case, and more about getting the word out that the 'test' Top Gear did was edited in a way that maximized humor vs. being 100% accurate.
- eli 13y agoSure, and that's probably a fair point. They should have said exactly that. Instead they implied the show maliciously falsified a review and then spent months (years?) unsuccessfully litigating them.
- fancyketchup 13y agoRight, and Tesla lost because Top Gear argued (successfully) in court that what they aired was not a review but a comedy show. And being that the review was not a review, it could not be a malicious review. That's very thin ice to be standing on.
- eli 13y agoI really think you are mistaken. Do you have a source that says that's why the case was dismissed? The Top Gear review was essentially accurate, at least IMHO. Tesla argued in court that it was unfair to mention the car's disappointing range on the test track because most people won't be driving on a test track. A strange argument, especially for a sports car. Note that they did not argue that the range number cited was wrong -- just that it might confuse potential buyers. The judge ruled that: "no reasonable person watching the programme could understand that the performance on the track is capable of direct comparison with the performance, including the range, on the road"
- eridius 13y agoI thought the problem was Top Gear showed them pushing the Tesla, as if it had run out of juice, when in fact it still had battery and could have driven under its own power?
- tokipin 13y agopart of the issue is how quick people are to judge, combined with the particular historical perception of electric cars. Tesla has to be very aggressive about the image of its vehicles, otherwise the prevailing prejudices about electric cars in general will override the image of its own cars regardless of how awesome they may actually be