4 ms·
I'm not sure I can agree with the article's claim that these experiments were necessary: "Without that terrifying two-headed dog, in other words, we’d all go d
by pavlov 13y ago
I'm not sure I can agree with the article's claim that these experiments were necessary:
"Without that terrifying two-headed dog, in other words, we’d all go down with our failing kidneys."
Eventually we would have found other ways to collect the data needed for safe organ transplants than using live mammals. It probably would have delayed the introduction of transplant procedures on humans, so in that sense there would have been "people going down with failing kidneys" -- but how much suffering can you justify by saying that it might save human lives down the road?
I'm reminded of Kazuo Ishiguro's excellent novel Never Let Me Go.
(--- Major spoiler alert! ---)
It takes place in a sort of parallel-universe Britain of the '70s and '80s where human cloning was invented just after WWII. Cloning has become the cure for cancer: just grow a steady supply of live clones, take their organs and transplant them to cancer-inflicted patients.... Of course it takes about 18 years to grow a clone, and you can't just keep these people in a vat somewhere. So the clones are people without citizen rights, whose sole mission in life is to be harvested eventually. Society sees this as justified because clones are not "real people" anyway -- and more importantly, nobody wants to turn the clock back to an era when people regularly died of cancer.
- jlebrech 13y agothat's the plot for 'the island'
- pavlov 13y agoI guess so. It's not an original sci-fi conceit as such. What I love about Ishiguro's book is how it's cast into a nostalgic past of about 1980, in an idyllic Summerhill-style boarding school, and the cloning alt-history scenario never takes precedence over the characters. The setup is just an ominous fateful presence that made me care very much for these young people who can never really even fathom avoiding their destiny, that it wouldn't be necessary for their days to be counted before they were even conceived.
- acqq 13y agoEventually we would have found other ways to collect the data needed for safe organ transplants than using live mammals. To start doing the transplants you have to actually do the transplants. Insisting on avoiding doing it on mammals, wanting to do on humans gives only one solution: would you really prefer to immediately experiment on humans instead of mammals?
- VladRussian2 13y agoputting second heart into a dog may look like some transplant experimentation. Butchering and sewing 2 dogs together - nope, it is 1959, it is for the "wow" effect in the show of "the Soviet science under the wise leadership of the Communist Party is the most advanced science in the world". No wonder that they freely let the LIFE journalists in.
- acqq 13y agoI suspect that you have no idea about surgery at all. Based on what do you claim that heart transplants are valid experiments and head transplants aren't? Only because of the shock effect? Try reading about the history of medicine: after Galen (second century common era), mostly thanks to different church/ideological dogmas, "doctors" (quotes because they were quite unsurprisingly unaware of the scientific approach) spent hundreds of years theorizing instead experimenting. Experiments of head transplantations are absolutely valid experiments. More recently and related, USSR had its own ideology-based suppression of valid scientific approach in biology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism
- jlgreco 13y agoEven things that seem like senseless "wow effect" butchering advance the state of science, if by nothing else than by establishing were our limitations are and are not. In this specific case, this work with dogs would later play a role in inspiring Dr. Robert White to attempt the same with monkeys. This larger body of work would then play a role in the development of new surgical techniques for humans, such as the use of therapeutic hypothermia that improves survival rates by dropping body temperatures (something 'played with' during head transplant experiments to keep the brains functional for a longer period of time.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- guard-of-terra 13y agoThat cure for cancer won't work for so many reasons.
- V-2 13y ago"how much suffering can you justify by saying that it might save human lives down the road?" - human suffering, or canine suffering? What is the 'exchange rate'? And fish suffering? A difficult problem. PS. It's certainly much easier to be the "eventually we would have found other ways"-humanitarian, being a healthy individual :)
- Fistandantilus 13y agoUsing clones to extend one's life is a similar theme in the book The House of the Scorpion by Nancy Farmer. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_House_of_the_Scorpion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_House_of_the_Scorpion