4 ms·
The linked article directly disagrees with this post (except the last paragraph, which itself disagrees with the rest of the post) Actually, Baez's article dis
by pdonis 13y ago
The linked article directly disagrees with this post (except the last paragraph, which itself disagrees with the rest of the post)
Actually, Baez's article disagrees with the last paragraph of RRC's post; in so far as it talks about what's in the rest of RRC's post, it basically agrees with it (the part at the beginning about the Wile E. Coyote stuff isn't really talked about in Baez' article, except in so far as it's supposed to illustrate that a static gravity field doesn't have to "propagate" at all).
Baez' article, and the paper by Carlip that is referenced in it (and by RRC) basically say that measurements like the binary pulsar show that this statement from RRC's post is, strictly speaking, false:
all the aberrations you might expect because of a finite speed of light end up canceling out, so gravity acts like it's instantaneous
The cancellation is not exact; that's why binary pulsar systems can lose energy by emitting gravitational waves. But it's very close to being exact, closer than the analogous cancellations for electromagnetism; that's why we don't observe "aberration" in the direction of the gravitational force to the same extent that we do for the electromagnetic force.