4 ms·
> To the absolute limit of our ability to measure it — and our ability to measure it is really good, since we used electromagnets and lasers and other expensive
by ok_craig 13y ago
> To the absolute limit of our ability to measure it — and our ability to measure it is really good, since we used electromagnets and lasers and other expensive science things — when an object is dropped, it begins falling instantaneously. Not after a very small interval of time, but absolutely instantaneously. As in zero time elapses between dropping and falling.
> This is fairly earthshaking, really. Because it implies that somehow a "signal" of some kind is getting from the ground to Wile E. faster than the speed of light. Which is supposed to be impossible.
I don't know a lot about physics and relativity but this actually seems to me how I'd expect it to be. I don't understand why people expect that there has to be an interaction before gravity starts, or that gravity is directed linearly between two masses (you and the earth). It's already being emitted, and you're stepping out off the cliff into a gravity wave that is already there. You're always in that wave. Now the thing beneath you preventing you from being pulled in is gone. No initial setup was required.
Imagine the same example with a light beam instead of gravity. At the foot of the cliff is a ball as bright as the surface of the sun, radiating light in every which way. If you step off the cliff, it doesn't take a few nanoseconds for the light to hit you, because you're stepping into a lightbeam that is already there. No interaction is necessary to set it up.
I dunno. This seems like the intuitive way to think about it to me. Anything else would seem strange. Maybe I'm misunderstanding?
- tedsanders 13y agoNo, I think you're right. RobotRollCall sets up a straw man with the Wile E Coyote example. Electric attraction travels at the speed of light, yet you would feel it right away after walking off a cliff.
- radarsat1 13y agoIn fact you "feel" gravity all the time, even when you're not falling... in the mechanoreceptors in your feet.
- jheriko 13y agodon't forget the 'sixth sense' - there are three little accelerometers in each of your ears, and cool little feedback control system that keeps your eyes constantly cancelling out the tiny variations in position that your head constantly undergoes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vestibular_system http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vestibular_system afaik its the only sense which doesn't primarily detect electromagnetic effects.
- radarsat1 13y agonot to mention that the force that your muscles are exerting to stay standing up continuously keep your brain informed about proprioception.