5 ms·
Here's another way to understand it. The difficultly: Despite the propagation delay, gravity always points to where the object should be, instead of where it w
by ars 13y ago
Here's another way to understand it.
The difficultly: Despite the propagation delay, gravity always points to where the object should be, instead of where it was when the gravity was "emitted".
The explanation: Just like the object itself is moving, the gravitational field (or electric/magnetic field) is ALSO moving! It moves at exactly the same speed, and in the same direction as the object which created it.
It's "disconnected" from the source - so if the source suddenly changes direction the field it emitted doesn't know about it, and continues to point to where it expected the object to be.
More technical:
Why wormholes are impossible, and why you can not create a single magnetic monopoles:
What about conservation of momentum? If an object is pulled to where the other object is expected to be, not where it is, then momentum exchange between the two of them would seem to not add up!
But it works because you can never create a gravitational or electric field from nothing. You can only move them around, so the momentum always catches up.
What about a magnetic field? You can create those from nothing - ah, but you can only create magnetic dipoles, with opposing fields, so again it works.
But, you can never create a magnetic monopole because you would suddenly have a magnetic "charge" where none existed before and the momentum would not add up. What you can do is create two monopoles, of opposite poles. (So this implies a conservation of magnetic pole, just like conservation of electric charge - assuming monopoles exist.)
What about wormholes? They have the same momentum problem - an object suddenly appears where none was before and it pulls on other objects. You could then move it away before it gets pulled in turn by those objects, and that would violate conservation of momentum. So you can't do that.
And, faster than light objects would have the exact same problem - they could move out of the area before they properly shared the momentum. So I suspect they can't exist either. (Unless there is some complicated math I didn't think of which "fixes" it.)
- Ygg2 13y agoWait, haven't they proven that you can make magnetic monopoles and that wormholes are still a possibility?
- gliese1337 13y agoIt is a prediction of some physical theories that magnetic monopoles could exist from the origin of the universe (and it kinda seems like they should, 'cause other than the existence of one kind of charge and the other, there's no good reason to see either half of electromagnetism as more fundamental than the other- both kinds of field can generate the other, and how much of each one you think you have depends on your inertial frame since they're relativistic transformations of each other), but no one has shown that you can make them, pulling the poles of a magnet apart like you can pull electrons away from protons.
- Semiapies 13y agoNow, here's the thing that confuses me. Say some advanced civilization can move around some large mass - an asteroid, a planet, a black hole, whatever, we'll just call it "the big mass". They can, at will, fly it back and forth between two distinct positions we'll call 0 and 1. And let's say some distance away - a light-year, say - they have an facility where they can measure with excruciating precision the force of gravity on a test mass. After isolating out all other known gravity sources, they can use the remaining vector of gravitation force to compute the current position of the original big mass - and whether it's at position 0 or position 1. Assuming they can drag around the big mass from one position to the other in a short amount of time, shouldn't the people at the remote facility be able to detect where the big mass is long before light could reveal its position? Couldn't they use those observations to receive a low-bandwidth, but faster-than-light message? How does relativity prevent that?
- ars 13y agoIt takes a while for the test mass to notice that the big mass moved. So the test mass is pulled in a direction where the big mass no longer is, but rather where it was.
- platz 13y agoto say it's "pulled in a direction where the big mass no longer is" seems incorrect, because above we have "whenever a gravitating object moves inertially, the gravitational acceleration vector at a point removed actually points at where the object actually is at a given instant", due to the cancellaction and abberation effects. "Indeed, the vector (2.5) does not point toward the “instantaneous” position of the source, but only toward its position extrapolated from this retarded data" (which is pretty much the same location)
- ars 13y ago> whenever a gravitating object moves inertially The object is not moving inertially. Someone is forcing it to change direction, which is the exact opposite of inertially.
- stcredzero 13y ago> The difficultly: Despite the propagation delay, gravity always points to where the object should be, instead of where it was when the gravity was "emitted". [citation needed] My understanding is that it points to where the object was, and that the change propagates at the speed of light as gravitational waves.
- ars 13y agoThat's what you would expect, but it results in unstable orbits. Instead as the object moves, the gravitational field it emits also moves, so you end up feeling the gravity where you would expect it to be if the field transmitted instantly. It's when the object emitting the field changes direction that things become interesting.
- gliese1337 13y agoTypical Sci-Fi wormholes have that problem, but there are nevertheless valid GR solutions that look a heckuvalot like wormholes. And they do obey all those conservation laws. One can think of it as the wormhole mouths being objects (made out of space rather than matter) that accumulate and lose conserved quantities like mass and momentum and charge as objects enter or leave them, or you can think of it as lines of force getting stretched out to pass through the wormhole mouths whenever an object moves through them, since the fields can't just shear off. Incidentally, this generally means that you have to be careful about balancing the mass flow in each direction through your wormhole, lest one mouth develop negative mass (and presumably antigravity) from too much stuff leaving it and the other mouth end up shrouded in a black hole.