3 ms·
> Offer free, unhindered family planning services. Seems to have little/no effect. > Curb the rampant influence of organized religion on private matters. Goo
by anamax 17y ago
> Offer free, unhindered family planning services.
Seems to have little/no effect.
> Curb the rampant influence of organized religion on private matters.
Good luck doing that without coercion, substituting a different organization's influence on private matters.
> Empower women and give them equal employment so they have more time to reach for their dreams and less time popping out kids to latch onto a single source of income personified as a male patriarch.
Nice theory, but there's plenty of "overbreeding" in societies where women work as much as/more than men.
"X is bad" and "Y is bad" does not imply that X and Y have anything to do with one another.
> Develop family farms and agriculture and introduce automation to the process, so farmers don't depend on their offspring for labor.
Wrong. Automation doesn't make kids useless. It actually makes them more useful. A ten-year-old girl without automation can't do nearly as much as a 17 year-old boy. The more automation, the closer they are in productivity. (Having actually worked on farms, I'm often amazed by what people say about working on farms.)
If you want to keep farmers from breeding, don't have family farms.
- mahmud 17y agoAllow me to answer your suspicion about availability of family planning service and its effect on reducing population growth. You probably have the West, specially U.S. in mind when you say it has no effect. I think you're forgetting the welfare-check incentive in baby-popping. Family benefits as they're in the U.S. seem to be optimized for the maximum yield of babies, and reduction of intact, 2-parent households. Single women simply get more buck for their bang (sorry!) here. And the fact that said benefits demand the removal of the father from the house, what you're left with are women raising children by themselves, and children of single moms becoming single parents themselves and going back to the system. Where generations ago they might have gone to the family farm or shop, now they're going to the family social worker to collect their own welfare checks.
- anamax 17y agoThe claim was that family planning services mattered. Pointing out that they have no effect when something else is present, which wasn't mentioned in the list of "what to do", doesn't support that claim. I'm quite sympathetic to the idea that many "welfare services" are failures in many ways, including population. Perhaps they should have been on the list from the beginning.