3 ms·
Related: As a means to fight cancer, large mammals have mechanisms to suppress telomerase and the other (alt) telomere repair mechanism. Small mammals like mic
by stcredzero 18y ago
Related: As a means to fight cancer, large mammals have mechanisms to suppress telomerase and the other (alt) telomere repair mechanism. Small mammals like mice do not have this. Why? It wouldn't help them. Even if the cancer cells in a tumor could not lengthen their telomeres, many of them would still get big enough to kill the host. (An inch-wide tumor might be no big deal for us, but for a little field mouse, it's as big as the whole body!) Hence, there is no evolutionary benefit to these mechanisms, and small mammals do not have them.
It could be that whales do get cancer, but since it's much harder proportionately for cancer to kill them as compared to merely large mammals like us, the cancer often goes undetected, and something else kills the whale. After all, finding 1 inch tumors in a whale would be like finding a needle in a haystack.
Cancer cells mutate rather rapidly, to the extent that this often impairs their function. If a cancer doesn't achieve and maintain efficient metastatis, it won't keep spreading. Perhaps whales have enough bulk that they can simply absorb being riddled with tumors in what constitutes a small fraction of their bulk, allowing them to ride the cancer out until it mutates itself past the point of efficient spread and survival.
- berntb 18y ago(Edit:Removed, so not to confuse people. Brain malfunction. Didn't get the point that without new metastasis, the article's point is that the mutations of a given tumor will kill it.)
- stcredzero 18y agoThe question involves both. Can the cancer spread to new sites fast enough to escape dying in its present sites?
- DavidSJ 18y agoSome of the descendant cancer cells might lose their capacity for spreading and survival, but wouldn't selection favor those that maintain it? Is there really any reason to believe that its reproduction fidelity is so low that there wouldn't be enough non-mutated cells in each generation?
- stcredzero 18y ago"spreading and survival" are contextual. "Cheater" cells might out-compete other tumor cells locally, but at the cost of the cancer surviving long term and successfully spreading elsewhere.