4 ms·
> Politics is how people agree between them (or are forced by others) to go about their lives. I want to be clear about my definitions to avoid semantic argume
by baddox 13y ago
> Politics is how people agree between them (or are forced by others) to go about their lives.
I want to be clear about my definitions to avoid semantic arguments. Sure, in a casual context the word is used that way (e.g. "office politics"). I mean to use the more specific definition, which refers to the organization of government, so I don't refer to all social organization as "politics." For another usage similar to mine, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-politics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-politics.
- parasubvert 13y agoThe point others are trying to make here is that it's completely self-serving to call one's political thought as Non-Politics. Libertarian/anarcho-capitalist thought and agorism is political in nature, making large (debatable) assumptions about how societal relations ought to be organized.
- baddox 13y agoBut you're still making a semantic argument, which is what I'm trying to avoid. I'm not arguing over what the "true meaning" of the word is. I have given my definition, and I would prefer that my statements be evaluated using those definitions.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoYou're claiming that having different politics (left-wing, right-wing, etc.) isn't a viable solution, only non-politics is a solution. And everyone else is saying that non-politics is still politics. But in order to be consistent with your claim that all politics are bad whereas anarchy is good, you have to claim that anarchy is not politics. At any rate, with non-politics everyone still governs their own body, so it's not unreasonable to view absolute anarchy as 7 billion different totalitarian nations.
- baddox 13y ago> You're claiming that having different politics (left-wing, right-wing, etc.) isn't a viable solution, only non-politics is a solution. It depends what you mean by "left-wing" and "right-wing." There are certainly a lot of differing beliefs which can be held without approving of politics. > But in order to be consistent with your claim that all politics are bad whereas anarchy is good, you have to claim that anarchy is not politics. You're still phrasing this like a semantic argument. I am not trying to argue what the "true meanings" of words are, because that's useless (although it's clearly a very attractive style of argument to many people in this thread). I have told you what definitions I am using, and clearly, anarchism is not politics according to my definitions. I would prefer you address the actual ideas I have expressed, rather than argue over "true meanings" of words. Also, I am not saying that all discussion of political philosophy is bad, because that field inevitably concerns itself with beliefs which advocate refraining from political activity. > so it's not unreasonable to view absolute anarchy as 7 billion different totalitarian nations. It is unreasonable if you want to have intelligent discussions using concise terms. That's why, if the members of a discussion are unable or unwilling to agree upon a few basic definitions, the only arguments available are semantic arguments. Thus, discussions involving the concept of "nations" or "states" should be based on an agreement of terms, and the only conceivable useful definitions for those terms would exclude individual humans.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoAs far as I can tell, reading upwards, your ideas are simply that politics are bad and non-politics are good. Are there any other ideas? The problem is precisely that you're defining terms to suit your arguments. All colors are bad, white is especially bad, therefore only the absence of color is good. But in many respects black functions just like the other colors. You can't say, well I'm defining terms like this, and it happens to suit me, so let's just discuss my ideas, namely that black is incredible, because it isn't a color. I don't agree with your axioms, so none of the claims in your system make logical sense. You're doing the same thing when you deny that an individual under absolute anarchy is equivalent to a state - presumably a state requires two or more people for you. Defending "your" land by yourself in the wilderness with a gun is still government. It's fine to discuss the form of government you like most - maybe anarchy is great - but it's intellectually dishonest to portray it as superior to all other governments because for some magical reason it is not a government and therefore does not contain any of the supposedly evil properties of governments, namely submission to the authority of another which inevitably gets abused. What you propose entails one of the most sinister consequences, namely that an individual's own authority, strength, and material wealth will be the final arbiter of power. My ideal is the exact opposite of global anarchy: one government, one currency, one set of rights, and no borders. But we can't have a reasonable discussion if my ideal is a priori terrible because it's political, and your ideal is wonderful because it's non-political / apolitical / whatever.
- coldtea 13y agoWell, your definition above is that politics "refers to the organization of government". So you want to be non-political with respect to that, ie. don't care about Washington, etc. Here is where the the problems arise: 1) Government is not just the one in Washington, but all kinds of government, ie. all kinds of collective decision making. You cannot avoid those. Any time you want to get to a decision some kind of government will emerge -- and as the decisions get more complicated or involve more people (and have to be enforced or else are nullified), it will have most of the regular government traits. 2) You cannot even avoid the regular government just because you prefer to be non political. If you want to do without "politics" (as defined in your definition) you still need to enter the political field (ie. you could face adverse action from Washington, you have to abide by their laws, etc). So even to be "non-political" you first have to abolish politics somehow, or you are still subject to them.